From a few of the emails I got, it sounds like some people thought the earlier discussion was more than just a hypothetical question thing! I probably should have clarified a bit more. Hasbro did not contact us to create a side series, it's just for fun.
We did also get a bunch of requests for a poll, so lets roll with it!
I can't add every response (There are way too many), but I've grabbed a few that I saw a few times, and combined a couple of others.
182 comments:
Doctor whooves RIGHT NOW !
ReplyDelete...Sadness weeps my soul.
ReplyDeleteOh Derpy :)
ReplyDeleteFirst voter of
ReplyDeleteAlicorn/Discord Equestrian History!
All the others would be inferior!
aww :(
ReplyDeleteLuna's School for Gifted Unicorns. RIGHT NOW!
ReplyDeleteThey all look pretty good, but I think I'll have to go with Daring Do on this one.
ReplyDeleteI threw a vote over to Octavia and Scratch.
ReplyDeleteVoted for alicorn/discord equestrian history
ReplyDeleteTrixie's Journey Across Equestria! If Trixie wasn't up there, I'd go with Daring Do.
ReplyDeleteITT we now all comment which poll option we voted for, despite the fact that this has no influence on the poll and we have already cast our votes in the poll.
ReplyDeleteOctavia and Vinyl please, and that's 100% just because I finished reading Allegrezza.
A discord/celestia would be cool. Dr whooves would be copy wright infringement sadly, so I'll go with daring do series
ReplyDeleteCan't decide between Doctor Whooves/Derpy time travel or Octy/Scratch >_<
ReplyDeleteToo many of these would work so well for me to choose.
ReplyDeleteOf those, Alicorn/Discord Equestrian History actually has a possibility of being a full episode. It's one of the reasons I really, really, want them to do a Celestia Episode this season.
ReplyDeleteto choose would be to deny the others, which i cannot do, they all sound so amazing. NEED ALL
ReplyDeleteI pride myself by being the only one do far to vote Other
ReplyDeleteNone of the choices applied to me but I'll sleep on it
ARGH! Some of these choices are so good, I just can't decide!
ReplyDeleteThe Bon-Bon/Lyra, Octavia/Scratch, and Derpy Mailmare choices are the most appealing to me, but I also like the Alicon/Discord one, too!
Rainbow Dash Show ALL THE WAY!
ReplyDeleteIf the Rainbow Dash show gets chosen
ReplyDeleteI'd better see the Shadowbolts make appearances
DERPY: THE MAIL MARE
ReplyDeleteWhat if we had a side series that was just all the side characters?
ReplyDeleteLooking at the oll...I have to choose ONE? ;-;
ReplyDeletePoll, even.
ReplyDeleteWho didn't think it was hypothetical? Reading comprehension for the win people.
ReplyDeleteAlicorn/Discord history gets my vote mainly because other then Luna, Celestia and Discord you can bring in a whole slew of new characters to the party. Also, possible to bring a change up of the theme of the show considering it's way back in the past.
Bah the more I think about it I think history would be a geat episode idea i'm not sure it would work as a series.
ReplyDeleteI think I like Daring Do, Octavia and Scratch (especially if it's misadventures)
I think Derpy would be great but again, I'm not sure about an actual series. Luna's would be fun but not sure i'd make it work without feeling like it's borrowing too much from other things.
Daring Do, Equestrian soldier action series.
ReplyDeleteLyra and Bon-Bon for sure. Though I'd give almost anything just to hear "The Tavi and Scratchy Shooooow!"
ReplyDeleteI really like all the choices, but the Rainbow Dash show would be an awesome show
ReplyDeleteA side series for our background characters would be good, but i cant leave without suggesting a backstory series detailing the princesses' beginnings, maybe telling us how long it took them to get those elements of harmony
ReplyDeleteI want to know more about the great and powerful Trixie!
ReplyDeleteUnsurprisingly, I voted for the shonen series.
ReplyDeleteMan, if I could draw, there would be so many pictures of the Mane 6 dressed as the Bronze Saints...
@Sgt Byrd Sweet Celestia! Same thing, I always loved Octavia and Vinyl though, being a music student myself, but this must happen, for the benefit of the equestrian society ofc.....
ReplyDeleteAww man. I totally thought that was real.
ReplyDeleteARRGH!
Still, Rainbow Dash show.
I knew it sounded too good to be true.
ReplyDeleteIf we're talking realistically, a Cutie Mark Crusader's side series sounds the most realistic.
ReplyDeleteThough I can imagine a Trixie traveling across Equestria thing if she went to maybe different locations to put on shows running into zany and wacky adventures and such having each place she goes another name for some real life place (Stalliongrad, Amareica, any one of the states IN Amareica, etc.) where we get to learn about their culture while watching a good story filled episode with Trixie in it. Also maybe random tag alongs in some episodes like the mane six and stuff.
i voted other because i want to see a snails, pip n snips show, in the style of ed, edd n eddy. thats a show
ReplyDelete@Christian
ReplyDeleteI loved that too. I want to know more about Celestia, Luna and Discord.
As cool as "Doctor Who with ponies" sounds, I'd rather have an excuse for more Luna, so I'll go with the Luna's School for Gifted Unicorns. Unless it turns out like Yu-Gi-Oh GX and Luna gets even less screen time than Bakura.
ReplyDeleteTrixie has the most character development possibilities of all of them. Everyone's so fixed on what would be COOL and AWESOME that they forget what's most important: Learning! Trixie could slowly learn about Friendship and other life lessons during her journey through Equestria and beyond. The other choices can't possibly compare!
ReplyDeleteBesides, magic shows would be totally META: Deconstructing the very stuff that makes each episode work. Trixie could break the 4th wall just as hard as Pinkie Pie occasionally.
I went for Alicorn/Discord Equestrian History, no-brainer. I would love to learn their backstory (Hopefully it's as epic as some of the fics' versions) and having the setting way in the past will give the opportunity for a complete change of pace and style.
ReplyDeleteIf it wasn't for inevitable copyright problems, my next choice would have been Derpy and Doctor Whoof Shenanigans. How can that NOT be a recipe for awesome? =D
I picked "Other" for "Celestia stars in a political drama or such."
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure why LUNA gets the School for Gifted Unicorns when that's canonically Celestia's...
The Derp!
ReplyDeleteI voted for "Adventures of Daring Do", but only if H8_seed's "Daring Mare" is used for the intro sequence.
ReplyDeleteOtherwise, CMC all the way. Lauren said that she made FIM with the idea in mind that there's more than one way to be a girl. The CMC could (and do, in some of the episodes that feature them) that there's more than one way to grow up.
I predict that the results of this poll will much more likely be a popularity contest of characters rather than what premise would make the best show. Le sigh.
ReplyDeleteOof...Can you change the poll to being check boxes instead of single answer?
ReplyDeleteI CAN'T DECIDE ON JUST ONE!
But I want to vote for all of those options D:
ReplyDeleteI personally like the concept of a Twilight Sparkle arc or a Rainbow Dash arc, as I think they would probably make the series more involved with the characters, which is something I've wished for the series since day one, but unfortunately have never gotten. I mean, I'm perfectly okay with all the one-off episodes, but an actual arc, in my opinion, would make the show significantly cooler in my eyes, and that's saying a lot, because the show is already cool enough as it is.
ReplyDeleteA Scratch/Octavia side show would be the next best thing though...
Vinyl Scratch & Octavia sounds like something that'd make a great musical.
ReplyDeleteRepost (sorry):
ReplyDeleteWhat about Princess at the begginig of Equestria. Two Alicorns learing to use their power, facing likes of Discord, trying to create better world for everypony. It would provide nice contrast to the main show, gives us opportunity to explore already important characters and will not interfere in any way with what Mane6 is up to (unless time travels will be involved)
I just had to give Trixie my vote.
ReplyDeleteIt would make the most Great and Powerful side series of all!
Daring-Do and Doctor Whooves are great and all, and I'd love to know Equestria's history, but the CMC have all of my love at the moment. (Only 82 votes?! This is unacceptable!)
ReplyDeleteVinyl Scratch and Octavia are good as well, but I'm not going to risk a whole side series on OCs that I may not like.
Trixies' Adventure should have more votes.
ReplyDeleteShould we restrict ourselves to the same "pre-teen male" demographic we were previously using, or is this just outright fanservice now? Not that I'd be complaining, but it would change my answer.
ReplyDeleteTempting as Doctor Whooves and Twilight magical shonen arc are, I'm going to go with Alicorn/Discord history. I imagine that would probably be a shonen arc as well.
ReplyDeleteWHAT ARE YOU PEOPLE DOING VOTING FOR DARING DO?? COME ON GUYS, THIS IS DERPY WERE TALKING ABOUT HERE.
ReplyDelete"Hasbro did not contact us to create a site series, it's just for fun." oh Derpy you and your derpy typo's <3
ReplyDeleteaaaarrrrgggggggg...
ReplyDeleteso hard to choose!
I saw a thing about Royal Gaurds going on missions, I'd really like that.
ReplyDeleteI have to say that there is a rich and varied fantasy world full of magic and monsters. You HAVE to have adventure in it. The best one to do it is the somewhat fictionalized stories of Daring Do. Although, I would accept Trixie or as yet unknown team of ponies doing the same.
ReplyDeleteI mean, you don't HAVE to do monster of the week, but you already have wonderful monsters. Land eels? Wolves made of wood? Dragons? What's next? Lightning Mushrooms?
I was a huge fan of magic girl shows before getting into Friendship is Magic so a Twilight centered mahou shoujo show really appeals to me.
ReplyDeleteShounen-style Twilight Sparkle Magic Arc?
ReplyDeleteGosh darn, I'm disappointed by the number (Or, lack, as it were) of votes behind that one as of now.
I'm somewhat surprised you didn't expect this, Seth. It's easy to get lost in the excitement of a show like this and take everything at face value. Maybe you should start using a "hypothetical" tag for that kind of post instead of "news".
ReplyDeleteDawwwwwww. I actually thought it was going to be real. ;_;
ReplyDeleteBut I feel like Dr. Whooves and Derpy would be a rip-off of Dr. Who.
Personally I'd love to see more back-story to the show that gets a bit deeper and darker than the current history given to us. So I voted for Alicorn/Discord Equestrian History.
ReplyDeleteWait, I don't see the poll. How do I get to it?
ReplyDeleteThe Adventures of Daring Do
ReplyDeleteDoctor Whoof and Derpy's Time traveling Shenanigans
OH GOD I CANT DECIDE
This whole poll is going to just scream bias everywhere from each corner of the world. (A show about Lyra and Bon-bon, what? No Starswirl and his OP magic with Woona sidekick ;_;)
ReplyDeleteThough, Equestria history and Discord would seem the best option, then Zebras and their black and white ways. Most of the others look horribly derived or just turning fanon to canon. Though, I do wonder how Trixie's luck fared in other towns/cities in the eyes of the producers.
One may say I'm taking it to seriously since it was only a discussion, but then I could argue the other may not be in the right discussion at all. The idea was to pitch something that'd be majorly appealing to the male youth (which I assume aren't those who watch the show) which involved ponies.
Nevermind I see it hah
ReplyDeleteI'm telling you guys. . . Adventure, Action, and more pony machismo then you can handle!
ReplyDeleteBraeburn!!! We need more of him and AAAAAAPPLELOOSA!
Luna's School for Gifted Unicorns hell yeah
ReplyDeleteInsanely hard to choose between Dash's Joins the Wonderbolts, or Cutie Mark Crusaders Full Spinoff. But I voted for the Cutie Mark Crusaders Full Spinoff because I think it could stay in line with the main show and who doesn't love the CMC's? Though I would love a show dedicated to Rainbow Dash too, hard choice indeed...
ReplyDeleteI picked Doctor Whoof and Derpy, but I'd rather see Twilight as his companion.
ReplyDeleteDerpy: The Male Mare
ReplyDeleteI can't vote. There are too many sweet choices. D:
ReplyDeleteLuna teaching! Then she has a reason why she isn't seen much!
ReplyDeleteI have to admit, though Rainbow being a Wonderbolt is tempting, I have to go with time-traveling shenanigans.
ReplyDeleteOh well there goes that. I should have known, it did say discussion board :facehoof: well at least i have another idea for a fanfiction. So im good I should really finish my other ones first or at least get cought up. FlutterYuu out!!!
ReplyDeleteDaring Do, a Doctor Whooves series, and an Alicorn/Discord History all sound really freaking awesome.
ReplyDeleteWhy didn't you add an "All of the above" option? It was extremely hard to choose.
ReplyDeleteVoted for Trixie's Journey. Daring Do and Doctor Whooves are fun, but I would rather see something completely original and not a whole series built on references.
ReplyDeleteAll of them are awesome. But more Alicorn history would be nice
ReplyDelete@Atomicmonkey
ReplyDeleteI believe Doctor Whoof and Derpy time traveling shenanigans could easily include ALL of these options.
I hear issue about copyright issues with Dr. Who, but beyond the name, what issue would there be? Surely a pony with the ability to travel through time and space (at will? unintentionally? slowly learns how to control it?) wouldn't get anyone into trouble. To me, that's like saying there's copyright issues between Dr. Who and The Time Traveler's Wife, or any time traveling thing - whichever came first. So we have a space-and-time traveling pony that can take other ponies (Derpy) with him. I don't think there should be any problems.
With Dr. Whoof and Derpy misadventures, we can see the beginnings of Equestria, the early days of Celestia/Luna, maybe meet the original inspiration for Daring Do (I just don't see Daring Do standing on her own...) maybe we can learn more about Zecora's origins and how/why she came to Ponyville, maybe some Everfree forest stuff, and see Discord's reign.
With Dr. Whoof and Derpy as the backbone, all the other things everyone wants to see can be incorporated. It would be amazing :)
Well I misunderstood the b*yay*ck out of that last post. Maybe I should try reading it next time. Not only did I think that a side series was in the making, but I thought it was for sure Daring Do.
ReplyDelete:derp:
I need to perfect my english and I'll flood you with millions of fics. Damn, in 15 minutes got 7 ideas of which at least 3 would make a fantastic fic. If I could write it properly ofc - my prereaders are less than gentle so far ^^
ReplyDelete@Iris Melody
ReplyDeleteThere should be no problems with simple time travelling story, but they will appear if you include TARDIS and sonic screwdriver.
Fuck Daring Do.
ReplyDeleteDARING DO! NAO!
ReplyDeleteWhy must you make me choose between Rainbow Dash and Daring Do?!
ReplyDeleteDaring Do, then.
@TheBanteringBrony
Must... resist...
I CAN'T CHOOSE! These are all great ideas.
ReplyDeletei am disapoint...
ReplyDeleteWould somepony mind telling me if "Luna's School for Gifted Unicorns" is an intentional X-men reference? Because if it is I'm leaning towards that, if not "Trixie's Journey Across Equestria" will likely get my vote.
ReplyDeleteOf the choices given, I think Dr. Whooves would be the best cartoon. Although a Wonderbolts series has potential also...
ReplyDeleteDaring Do would never make it as a series, sadly. It's a fun diversion but not a viable spinoff IMHO.
Luna's school for gifted unicorns - as in Winter Magic Academy?
ReplyDeleteI'm ok with this.
and why is mane 6 background characters not an option? (Derpy, Dr. Whooves, Lyra, Bon Bon, Tavi, Scratch)
shoulda realized :P hindsight is 20/20 i guess...
ReplyDeleteWhat!? What is this folly?? We only get to pick one!?
ReplyDeleteUnacceptable! Make AAAAALLLLL of them, I say!
school for gifted unicorns sounds like a good idea so that's what I chose.
ReplyDeleteWait, people actually thought it was real?
ReplyDeleteOh well.
I'm not voting.
ReplyDeletethere's just too many good ideas on there for me to pick just one.
Someone need to steal all of them in make them into Fan fics,comic, and flashes.
My picks:
The Adventures of Daring Do
Doctor Whoof and Derpy's Time traveling Shenanigans (DBR is already doing this and it really good)
The Every Day Lives of Lyra and Bonbon (I been wanting someone to make a comic series with this concept.)
Dash's Joins the Wonderbolts (AKA The Rainbow Dash Show) (Yes yes 100 times yes.)
Cutie Mark Crusaders Full Spinoff (very interesting)
Trixie's Journey Across Equestria (I wonder if we can handle that much Trixie)
Octavia and Scratch (So want!)
Derpy's Mailmare Chronicles ( who doesn't want a Derpy Spin-off?)
Luna's School for Gifted Unicorns
(Who doesn't want more Luna?)
whatever, I just want doctor whooves!
ReplyDeleteI can't choose! so many of those sound awesome!
ReplyDeleteSo there isn't going to be a side series. Well that sucks.
ReplyDeleteDaring Do travelling to strange places across Equestria, collecting mythical items in a similar fashion to "The Librarian"(look it up). Perhaps doing special task for Princess Luna who remembers better the ancient items from before her imprisonment.
ReplyDeleteThe fate of Equestrian knowledge rest on Daring's Wings! The power in these items could threaten balance throughout the land!
(Just an idea). Like?
Equestria before Discord and Nightmare Moon were imprisoned.
ReplyDeleteThis choice is the most difficult decision I faced in my whole life. SO many awesome options, I'd die to know about Discord/Princesses story but also would love to see Bon Bon and Lyra's life as well as RD epic story about joining the wonderbolts; and Trixie epic adventure??! FFFFF- I can't decide at all.
ReplyDeleteOctavia and DJ, want so bad!
ReplyDeleteOpinion seems to be divided on this subject too many awesome choices!
ReplyDeleteLuna side story
ReplyDeleteCome on a little more Lyra Bonbon here, how can the life of a entusiastic, musicloving over the top pony live her life whit down to earth Bob bon sound less exiting than all other ideas.
ReplyDeleteLyra would'int even stopp crime whit her magic she would do it like an earth pony, just for Bon bon.
JESUS CHRIST, EQD. You work hard on this blog, yes, but STOP posting unfounded news and making misleading posts like this one. You got EVERYONE'S hopes up. I hate you right now.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteA series similar to Wishbone where the ponies read stories similar to the original such as The Odessy or 1984. Not only would it have that but more Daring Do as a small side stories. That way Hasbro could market Daring Do books and children would be encouraged to read classic literature.
ReplyDeleteAre we coming up with serious suggestions or spitballing? if it were official, gimme a weekly super-duper pinkie pie power hour. if we're wildly fantasizing, Fallout Equestria. God, I would kill to see a well-animated FO:E series, and serial murder for the entire story to be adapted.
ReplyDeleteI picked the Doctor Whooves choice, but let it be known that I'd rather have Derpy replaced with Twilight.
ReplyDeleteActually I kinda believe it at first, but then I thought about how making a show "aimed at a younger male audience" would go against the concept that Faust had at first. Also when Sethisto posts News he doesn't put the Discussion tag.
ReplyDeleteI felt silly! xD
The Every Day Lives of Lyra and Bonbon sounds like a late-90s sitcom.
Cool!!
Someone brought this up in the Drawfriend, and it's by far my favorite (realistic) idea for a spin-off series: MLP:FiM:TNG, featuring the adventures of Pipsqueak, Scootaloo, Apple Bloom, Snips, Snails, Dinky, and Spike.
ReplyDeleteDr. Whoof! Dr. Whoof! If you wanted, you could easily combine the two, since the TARDIS can basically go to anywhere at anytime.
ReplyDeleteHow could you possibly impose this choice upon us, Seth? There are too many epic choices on this list!
ReplyDelete*looks at poll choices*
ReplyDeleteFFFFUUUUUUUUUUU!!!!
Now instead of too few choices, there are too many! How will I ever decide which hypothetical side series is best?
I know, I'll make them fly through a dangerous gorge! Ohwait; I can't. That doesn't even apply here ಠ_ಠ...
This poll's gonna keep me up tonight...
Aw, come on bronies; at least have Dr. Who over Daring Do.
ReplyDeleteFor Christ's sake! We don't need a damn Daring Do spinoff if she already had spotlight! Just choose Derpy being a mailmare. It's a no-brainer.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDoctor Whooves & Derpy as the Assistant
ReplyDeleteMAKE IT HAPPEN!
While all these ideas are fantastic, I have to say, a Zebra spinoff would make my day.
ReplyDeleteEspecially if we'd get to learn more about Zecora.
Equestria Daily, I am disappoint. You twisted my heartstrings, but turned them too far. Now they're snapped. :(
ReplyDeleteTwilight/Trixie magic arc.
ReplyDeleteAwww :( I genuinely belived they asked that was getting so excited :(
ReplyDeleteSO MUCH GOOD STUFFZ... Why can't I choose all of them?
ReplyDeleteIdiot. You know goddamn fucking well the original post was extremely misleading in its wording and was intended to be so. Don't try playing innocent. Not all of the people here are retarded. Most are, but not all.
ReplyDeleteIf it were possible, I'd say Doctor Whooves and Derpy. Sadly, I don't think that could ever happen, so I'd have to vote for Derpy's mailmare antics.
ReplyDeleteI almost voted for the CMC spinoff, but I couldn't stand the thought of a spinoff just being a retread of the main show a la Family Guy & American Dad.
ReplyDeleteFor a new show it has to be something fresh and new. So I voted for the Twilight Magic Arc.
I'd love a action series where Twilight kicks ass, powers up and kicks more powerful ass.
Daring-Do! Because that would be awesome and full of potential. I love Doctor Whooves and Assistant but that's really best left to the guys who make the episodes on youtube.
ReplyDeleteA shounen style adventure is exactly the kind of thing I've been hoping that this series would turn into. Too bad this option only guarantees Twilight's involvement. Oh well, I'll vote for it anyway.
ReplyDeletedaring do spin-off would be awesome also something new like equestria police department or an adventure with fancy pants as a super spy or something like that
ReplyDeleteI really like the idea of a Lyra & BonBon series... kind of a slice-of-life Lucky Star / Azumanga Daioh / Yotsuba& style four-panel series.
ReplyDeleteThen I saw "Luna's School" and my brain almost locked up in a "BlueScreen-Of-Derp"ed. Lyra & BonBon won by a narrow margin, but I would enjoy reading about the Moon Princess's school and the nocturnal fillies and colts attending it: 1) Lots of coming-of-age storylines for background and OC foals alike, 2) rivalry drama full of Enemy_Mine, Rivals_Team_Up, 3) Big_Damn_Heroes moments, and 4) throw in your choice of TvTropes Youngsters archetypes: Cute_Bruisers, Little_Miss_Bad*sses, Bumblebees, Military_Brats, Tykebombs, Child_Prodigies, Bad*ss_Adorkable, you name it.
I feel a Twilight Sparkle Magic arc could also be quite the storyline could but it could be overwhlemingly involved and complicated (exploring the fundamental magical mechanics of the series is srs bzns), so I put it underneath
I want more to see more of Pinkie Pie's trombone.
ReplyDeleteSo hard to choose Gah!!!! (pulls out mane)
ReplyDelete... Well i'm gonna head to Rarity's boutique for a wig and vote for Octavia and Scratch
I know it was an hypothetical case, like the "now you're ".x." pony..." but... just for fun:
ReplyDeleteSETHISTOOOOOOO!!!!!!
@Something To Quack About
ReplyDeleteWhy are you even here? Every post I've ever seen you make has been rude, condescending, and angry.
*Apologies for the long post but...*
ReplyDeleteI did a lot of creative brainstorming, here's what I think you need to do if you want to make a spin-off.
- Keep essentially the same world but explore more of it or different kingdoms.
- Don't stress continuity with the first series too much.
- Consider appealing to the ancillary demographic without completely breaking free of the original. Meaning more action, more magic, maybe a few main male characters. But still cute. Like if it got a couple doses of Powerpuff Girls feeling perhaps. Where it can appeal to many different groups. As you see with fan productions, you can do just about anything with ponies.
I can see with season two they are making a lot of openings to spin-off the show. I know Hasbro loves money so if they can launch a new line of toys around a new series, they're sure to be happy. Here’s my thoughts on what might work.
The Adventures of Daring Do - You'd need to tweak things a bit but I would love to see a show on TV which reminded me of classics like Talespin or Ducktales. You could even borrow some of the structure. A mixture of slice of life-y shows and adventure ones. You'd need to come up with a group of characters surrounding Daring Do but the internet has already started brainstorming that. Could work.
Luna's School For Gifted Unicorns - I've honestly always found Luna to be a much more compelling character than Celestia. A lot of potential. You have a group of young unicorns discovering their abilities. Evoke magical girl shows or Harry Potter in your pitch. I'd love to see it develop characters who learn and change and grow. With Luna, a character who has made a lot of mistakes in her past, you have a compelling mentor.
Cutie Mark Crusaders Full Spinoff - You can see the format from their episodes. I'd focus on the school and develop a lot of the other characters. Your pitch would be something like the school episodes of Little House on the Prairie.
Doctor Whoof and Derpy's Time traveling Shenanigans - Biggest problem, rights to naming. This one would need to wait till we see how time traveling might be established in the show in that upcoming episode. You’d would want all the danger and whimsy of a Doctor Who episode and maybe some serial quality. Maybe borrow from Back to the Future and make Whoof a quirky inventor with a time machine. Borrow from Gyro Gearloose maybe.
Trixie's Journey Across Equestria - Can an antagonist really make it as a main character? Maybe you postulate Trixie decides to go back and really study magic and get good at it and put her hoof where her mouth is. I could imagine her amidst something of a traveling circus with an interesting array of characters.
Dash's Joins the Wonderbolts (AKA The Rainbow Dash Show) – Only if you make it to just be about the Wonderbolts...The Wonderbolts...as a title is really cool. You make it about them. You have a different, rookie character trying to get on the team.
Derpy's Mailmare Chronicles - Not sure. Maybe borrow judiciously from Talespin and their delivery antics.
Alicorn/Discord Equestrian History - Make the Silmarrilion of MLP? Well...actually that might be interesting but you first need to really come up with some interesting characters or make it an anthology show which deals with little bits of history. Maybe it can be like a Masterpiece Theater of Spike introducing stories of pony history in his smoker robe (looking good Spike...LOOKING REEEEAL GOOD!).
Something with Zebras - This is the part where the writer screams and runs away because he has to write rhymes day after day.
Seth, there's a problem with the poll - there's no "All of the above" option!
ReplyDeleteI voted for Luna's school for gifted unicorns for the following reasons
ReplyDelete-Luna
-School settings and magic are always fun together (Harry Potter/Negima)
-Has potential for slice-of-life and action
-Luna
-Takes place in Canterlot most likely
and finally
Luna!
More alicorn side stories and ponies beside Celestia And Luna
ReplyDeleteI'd love to learn more about Equestrian history.
ReplyDeleteConsidering that the original question was to consider a show that would be appropriate to target to a young male audience, I disregard the viability of most of these poll options as they are more a reflection of current fan popularity in characters.
ReplyDeleteI like the consideration that Sarah above put into this and they make some interesting analysis, but I'll go ahead and make some judgments myself.
Daring Do: Somewhat viable, but I think there are major obstacles in keeping with the FiM appeal since it is basically a different universe and there isn't a terribly good way of reconciling the two. I feel like the morality basis is pretty integral to why we enjoy FiM and they would need to dilute the focus on Daring Do in order to meet that order. Also, if the character is so far removed from the main FiM universe, I worry it would really just feel like a cheap Indiana Jones knock off.
I think a better take on this idea would be to use, say, Pip the Adventurer in a more grown-up form.
And not just because I have harbored deep longings for such a spin off series ever since I saw the first fan art. Not only do I think he would be more appealing to viewers who never got into FiM, but it would allow some great ability to retain a connection with the older fans by allowing for some other character continuity. Twilight, for example, would make a great mentor character for Pip to correspond to in order to relay his adventures so as to convey the message of each story. Another great twist they could pull is him writing to Princess Luna. You could even make one of the CMC his sidekick. (Scootaloo most obvious choice. You can make your main character more thoughtful and cognizant of moral dilemma if you've got a brash sidekick to balance).
And as an aside, I think this kind of series would be the best hope for fan-favorite one-shot characters to allow them to perform in their element. (Even room for epic characters like Discord perhaps?)
As far as the world goes, I think we've all seen that Equestria is well dangerous enough for an adventurer, what with dragons, manticores, timber wolves, ursa majors, and all manner of terrible creatures and magics. Heck, that's just Ponyville.
...I was going to comment on the other poll options as well, but I think maybe I'll just leave it since I got way sidetracked.
Where is this poll? I wish to vote for some Daring Do right now!!
ReplyDeleteHm, well just briefly. I think the Alicorn/Discord history, Lyra and BonBon, and Trixie journey ideas completely neglect the cerebral experiment I thought the original post was suggesting. If the point was to make a show geared towards young males (and most logically a focus on those who aren't already fans), these plots aren't readily appreciable by those not already ingrained in the fandom. Nor do I think the characters stand well enough on their own.
ReplyDelete@magnus_dune
ReplyDeleteSee the light blue column just to the right? The poll's in that column, near the top of the page.
I choose Other - Fallout: Equestria for the win! :)
ReplyDeleteOh dear Celestia, I just CAN'T DECIDE!!! D:
ReplyDeleteMore about Applejack in her rodeos.
ReplyDeleteThen my lfie is complete.
@Ulrik I mean life
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThinking about this again, I say a Spike spin-off would probably make the most sense, if the target audience is non-brony young boys.
ReplyDeleteGuys... Doctor Whooves would never work as an actual show. There's already a real Doctor Who. It's kind of silly to honestly believe it'd be a good spin-off.
ReplyDeleteDaring Do is the only good choice, on that list at least.
Pip the Actual Pirate ftw.
Anyone who thinks Doctor Whooves is a good idea deserves a good smack to the head. Seriously. And the same goes to all of the other "background pony gets their own show!" ideas. 'cause there's no way it'd match the fanon and so everyone'd get pissy. Also, there's no way Hasbro'd get the rights from the people who genuinely own Doctor Who.
ReplyDeleteNow, me, I kinda want a Trixie Show (if only so she can come back because she's a fun character with a lot of room for depth and growth), but bearing in mind the hypothetical audience is young non-brony males? Daring Do is the only choice on the list I can see appealing to little boys.
I voted for Luna's school, but honestly, how the hell am I supposed to choose between such awesome.
ReplyDeleteWhy don't I see "All of the above"? :P
ReplyDeleteIf you add the two with Derpy, she gets 28% atm.
ReplyDeleteSeth, when this poll is finished, you should make a new poll with the top 5 or something like that.
ReplyDelete@Author-Man
ReplyDeleteThey don't necessarily need across-the-board full rights to Dr. Who if they can work out some sort of collaboration and content-sharing operation between studios.
Come on guys, we need more luna! We've only seen her twice. Who knows what could happen in a school for unicorns, where they can't fully control their powers?!
ReplyDeleteThat or the shonen style twilight thing. I would enjoy seeing twilight use epic fighting magic.
ReplyDeleteI only want that one small scene of Whooves walking into a inconspicuous blue box somewhere in the background of a episode, and my life would be complete.
ReplyDeleteI would definitely watch a Daring Do mini-series. And apparently I'm part of a small minority that really doesn't like Derpy and Dr. Whooves.
ReplyDeleteCurveball: Griffin Kingdoms, the entics of inter-kingdom relations of Griffons and Pony. Chance to do less of the sappy stuff and focus on more of the hard edged Griffons. Celestia or Luna could Guest-spot.
ReplyDeleteThose are all great ideas, some more than others, but its so hard to choose!
ReplyDeleteI'd like to see a Crusaders spin off, maybe as a satire of preschool shows.
ReplyDeleteC'mon folks, a Lyra and Bon-Bon series would be comedy gold. Every episode Lyra gets enthusiastic about doing something in a human-like way that no one else even slightly understands, usually in a way that requires a device from DERPCO, the Acme Labs of Equestria.
ReplyDeleteEpisode 1: The Bicycle
Episode 2: Cutlery
Episode 3: Gloves
Episode 4: The Automobile
Episode 5: Power Tools
Episode 6: The Handgun
Episode 7: Heavy Machinery
Episode 8: Bows and Arrows
Episode 9: Doorknobs
Episode 10: Opening Bottles
Episode 11: Shoes & Socks
Episode 12: The Bowling Alley
Episode 13: Pants!
(On the off chance someone ever decides to do something awesome like that, I'm just going hereby license my episode list above CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION, do whatever you want with it.)
ReplyDeleteI finally decided on Derpy's Mailmare Adventures... Oh yes, the kinds of adventures SHE'D get it!
ReplyDeleteWith Dinky, Carrot Top, and Raindrops as supporting characters! :D
that's what you get for asking fandom
ReplyDeletethey wanted a side show for young boys I'm sure they would love Lyra and Bonbon or Octavia and Scratch series...
this both terrifies me and amazes me- adrenaline rush i'll be back after the 100th person
ReplyDeleteBrony: More balloons. Nah, too many balloons. More candy! Oh, less candy! Oh wait, I know! STREAMERS!
ReplyDeleteHasbro: Streamers?
Brony: Whose show is this?
The Adventures of Daring Do Please!
ReplyDeleteDARING DO.
ReplyDeleteWhy can't I vote for ALL OF THEM?
ReplyDeleteof course i want the Daring Do spin-off is by far the better option
ReplyDeletebesides did hasbro/HUB actually made the Dr Whooves being a Dr Who? i mean the TARDIS has made a cameo? & did he even has been close to derpy? i mean i have nothing against the idea of a Derpy Dr Whooves parody of Dr Who ...but that's more fandom than cannon, unlike Daring Do adventures wich actually takes a whole episode :/
@artista-AF warning long comment:
ReplyDeleteactually i would like a CMC spin-off too, but the problem is that there's already episodes of them & even if it would be hilarious the problem is that there won't be too much diference with FiM of course they could begin the series with a few chapters in ponyville & then after have tryied everything in there they should travel all over equestria to find their cutie marks ,that also would be a great chance to see other locations of Equestria besides Canterlot,Ponyville & the Everfree forest (but that would be the same interest of the Trixie's spin-off) .It would be mostly like The Cleveland Show formula, is the same than the main show but they have to change the background so it wouldn't be a Family Guy episde with another main character
-about the spin-offs of the supporting cast: actually it depends of how development of the characters IE: a show of PON-3 & octavia would be awesome but the problem is that they're mostly fandom, i mean do they even speak in the show? that's the problem of the thin line between canon & fandom, and the same applies to Derpy ,if hasbro/HUB would make a Spin-off wouldn't they do it of characters they actually have developed enough to at least have a chapter .Let's use the Madagascar movies as Example both movies has a huge supporting cast & many of them would be perfect fannon material ,but why dreamworks choose the Penguins & king Julien? becauce they're the most developed funny characters but inside the canon.
-about Zecora & the other zebras: well besides being a pain in the ass for the writters becauce of the rhymes but maybe not all the zebras speak n rhyme, maybe zecora is the rhyming weirdo i dunno & as i said im curious to see the rest of the pony world
-the Hystory of Equestria: it would be a cool show for the fanbase ,but how good would be for the real target audience of MLP? wouldn't be a bit too dark? considering the legends of Nightmare Moon & how miserable was suposed to be the life of the Equestrians during the Discords's ruling
-the Twilight's spin-off: errr isn't she already the main character of MLP:FiM already? i mean really what's the point of maiking the spin-off of the characters that actually are the main character. i mean would you make a The Simpsons spin-off about Homer? But ok let's consider that someone would make this "spin-off". it wouldn't be a re-make? or a whole new MLP series?
-Dash in the wonderbolts: i think this is more plot for the main series than a spin-off but who knows maybe it would work
sorry if i spamed too much but that's my opinion & i hope you can understand it ,becauce im not sure if i explained myself well XD
One option, and one option only.
ReplyDeleteQUEEN OF BRAVES! GAOPAIGAR!
"Princess! Sunbright is requesting Friendship Fusion!"
"FRIENDSHIP FUSION: APPROVED!"
I have an idea for what it could be... The show could be called. "Daring Do and Friends".
ReplyDeleteThis could make it so the side series could have different characters instead of just being focused on one single character. Plus it could just be shorts involving characters of less involvement/importance, which would include all background ponies/characters,Discord,Luna,etc.
DrWhoves -- definitely copyright infringy.
ReplyDeleteDaring Do -- better but too close to a 'Raiders of the Lost' series for comfort.
I read through a bunch of suggestions but haven't found anyone who's considered a series about the Wonderbolts. Any takers on that?