First one was good, second one's been done before, it's called Filly to the Future. 3rd was Meh, If there should be any level of quality control it should be no duplicates.
1. Never seen the show (movie?), but very well made video. 2. Pretty good. 3. http://s3.amazonaws.com/kym-assets/photos/images/original/000/100/460/kjhg.png?1297988895
How in the hell can people get tired of these? The first two were magnificently done. Characters were consistent and the clips from the show perfectly matched the characters' actions and emotions. So what if the same clips get used often? The context is always different and even the most overused clip can be put to fantastic effect if done right.
#1 - I don't even associate the English dub voices of Bebop with the characters, so the first one completely loses me with the piss-poor dubs of 90s anime...
#2 - Sure the premise is funny, but there is NO WAY to sync available pony clips to make any sense with this trailer. It just doesn't work.
#3 - I'm personally a fan of Nyan Cat, so I liked it...but it's not original, and probably didn't require a whole lot of editing or creativity. Did it really deserve the EqD spotlight???
As I've posted before, this kind of sub-par "PMV" post makes me FAR less likely to pay attention to ANY of them. Please, please implement some type of YouTube content screener based on the opinions of PROVEN quality, pony-related video creators (as you did with pre-readers and fanfics).
There used to be so few pony videos that they DID all deserve to be posted...but now...I love that everypony is flexing their creative muscles, but not all of those muscles are ready for primetime (which EqD IS in this fandom). That seems to be the message that EqD had put out to fanfic writers, and I think it should be equally applied to YouTube content. Just my 2 cents, and if you don't agree, feel free to ignore me. I promise I won't mind :) This is the last time I'll post my full opinion on this matter, and the last time I'll view multiple PMV posts, since I'm already subbed to the video/music makers that I know produce quality stuff.
27 comments:
inb4 first
ReplyDeleteOh nyan cat, what do you not make amazing....
ReplyDeleteHell yes.
ReplyDeleteHell yes.
Err, okay.
~Dark~
Oh shit son, am i about to get the first three comments?
ReplyDeleteAnd so, "Nah" lost all meaning and importance...
ReplyDeleteNyanJack was mediocre I gotta say...
ReplyDeleteNahjack?
ReplyDeleteMan, I was hoping the Pony Bebop The Movie would have been for the into like it was for the other one. Not the trailer.
ReplyDeleteFirst one was good, second one's been done before, it's called Filly to the Future. 3rd was Meh, If there should be any level of quality control it should be no duplicates.
ReplyDeleteNyanjack sounds... creepy...
ReplyDeleteThe trailer is gooood...
Oh, and the jack's animation was kinda good, but the audio steals your soul
@Anonymous
ReplyDeleteDon't you mean,
Oh ponies, what don't you make at least 20% cooler.
New Back to the future video > Old back to the future video.
ReplyDelete1. Never seen the show (movie?), but very well made video.
ReplyDelete2. Pretty good.
3. http://s3.amazonaws.com/kym-assets/photos/images/original/000/100/460/kjhg.png?1297988895
Wow, my two all-time favorite movies and the meme I find least annoying. I LOVE THIS POST.
ReplyDeleteHow could you NOT use Spike for Pony Bebop!? Honestly! Fail.
ReplyDeleteBack to the future trailer was already made.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgPmTGfHk98
it requires 1.21 gigawats
ReplyDeleteWhen this pony hits 88mph, you're gonna see some serious manure.
ReplyDeleteHow in the hell can people get tired of these? The first two were magnificently done. Characters were consistent and the clips from the show perfectly matched the characters' actions and emotions. So what if the same clips get used often? The context is always different and even the most overused clip can be put to fantastic effect if done right.
ReplyDelete#1 - I don't even associate the English dub voices of Bebop with the characters, so the first one completely loses me with the piss-poor dubs of 90s anime...
ReplyDelete#2 - Sure the premise is funny, but there is NO WAY to sync available pony clips to make any sense with this trailer. It just doesn't work.
#3 - I'm personally a fan of Nyan Cat, so I liked it...but it's not original, and probably didn't require a whole lot of editing or creativity. Did it really deserve the EqD spotlight???
As I've posted before, this kind of sub-par "PMV" post makes me FAR less likely to pay attention to ANY of them. Please, please implement some type of YouTube content screener based on the opinions of PROVEN quality, pony-related video creators (as you did with pre-readers and fanfics).
There used to be so few pony videos that they DID all deserve to be posted...but now...I love that everypony is flexing their creative muscles, but not all of those muscles are ready for primetime (which EqD IS in this fandom). That seems to be the message that EqD had put out to fanfic writers, and I think it should be equally applied to YouTube content. Just my 2 cents, and if you don't agree, feel free to ignore me. I promise I won't mind :) This is the last time I'll post my full opinion on this matter, and the last time I'll view multiple PMV posts, since I'm already subbed to the video/music makers that I know produce quality stuff.
pinkie pie as ed == yes
ReplyDeleteClose to awesome.
ReplyDeleteFrickin' sweet.
No ... just no.
"Scootaloo Watanabe"
ReplyDeleteThat is now her full name in my personal canon.
All three were pretty nice.
ReplyDelete1, 3 were great
ReplyDelete2 yeah...
one star because 2 failed so hard.
Applejack... + Nyancat... = ...... OMFG!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteWhen this filly hits 768 mph, you're going to see some serious horse apples.
ReplyDelete