• Discussion/Editorial: Ponies As A Creative Outlet


    If you had told me at the beginning of this year that I would be writing this, I would have given you a very odd look and went back to reassembling my computer, because I was replacing a motherboard at the time.

    This article is after a page break, because it's a lot longer than I thought it was going to be. The tags do not lie this time.



    I joined the fandom, as much as anypony can say that they 'joined' the adorable squishy mass that is ponies, around the middle of January on 4chan's /co/ board. I was using this very name, even- despite, of course, the fact that tripcodes were generally frowned upon. This was before we had separate chans, like Ponychan, so /co/ was basically the only place to go for ponies. Equestria Daily was in its infancy, and the Pony General thread locator was considered top-of-the-line in pony organization. How far we've come really is a sight to behold. This blog garners 200,000 hits a day.

    One of the most striking things about my time on that board was the amount of original content being produced every single day. Back then, of course, fiction wasn't as common, but you more often than not had very talented artists doing sketches and paintings of these marshmallow ponies and posting them for everypony to see. On-model, humanized, crossovers with other cartoons and video games; you name it, and it had been drawn. Sometimes artists would come in and just draw whatever ponies asked them to. This practice still continues today, of course. It was the main reason I stuck around on the board as long as I did.

    It wasn't really the fact that talented artists existed on the board that was so enthralling. After all, this was the comics and cartoons board. You're bound to attract some decent artists to such a place. It wasn't even the fact that a cartoon was generating so much art; much more well-known and 'serious' cartoons and comics got original art from fans all the time. It was commonplace.

    It wasn't either of those things that stuck out. It was the idea that it was My Little Pony of all things that was generating such content that had staying power in everyones mind. And in mine.

    It was barely two or three weeks of lurking around in these threads that I decided to write something that I hadn't written in a very long time- fan fiction. I had written stories for other universes before, and had even started a novel of my own, but those projects all sort of fell by the wayside after a time. I just wasn't motivated to finish them for whatever reason I could make up in my mind. For some reason, these ponies had made me care about writing again. You could say I was inspired by the sheer creative juices flowing out of the fandom as a whole. I wrote a small (only slightly longer than this article) vignette about Trixie, copied it into an image, as was the common practice at the time, and posted it on the board. I think maybe two ponies commented on it. It most certainly wouldn't have made it onto the blog today. I didn't care. I had contributed, and it felt great.

    Fast-forward to today. The blog gets so much original content in a single day that it made those early months look like a drought. Videos, music, fiction, and most certainly art. And then there's the things that no one expected- amazingly detailed custom recolors of the (admittedly) cheap official plastic toys, hand-coded games, and glassware, to name but a few. All in the name of ponies.

    Let me say that one more time. All in the name of little multi-colored marshmallow ponies.

    I'm sure what I'm about to ask you all is a question you've asked yourself many times. I ask it of myself every time I really stop and think about what I do every day for the blog. What is it about these little ponies that inspires such creativity in people that they normally wouldn't have had any inclination to express? My story is far from unique; even in the 300-word and speedfic events, I couldn't tell you how many times I read the words, "this is my first fan fiction." It still comes as a surprise to me when I read that and find a story that's really excellent. Ponies inspired that person to write something worth reading. The same goes for art. I've seen ponies admit that they had never considered drawing things before these equines came along. Each and every one of them had gotten past whatever artificial stigma exists around the brand (or ignored it entirely), found something inspiring about it, and used it in a positive way to express themselves.

    I've been in a few fandoms, and I'll be honest: I've never seen anything like this. It's wonderful, and I'm glad to be a part of it.

    So, let me close this article with a question: what is it about these ponies that you think inspires us to do these things in their name? I'd like to hear your thoughts on the matter.

    229 comments:

    1. THIS SHALL NOT GET FIRST

      ReplyDelete
    2. Personally I'm writing 'Hoennshy' so I can practice writing novel length stories. All the complexities of characters have already been fleshed out, so that allows me to work on my world building and event progression.

      Part of being an artist, well a paid artist, means you might have to be able to replicate the personalities and traits or even style of other franchises, so this helps me in that process as well.

      Plus it's just fun.

      ReplyDelete
    3. silly. It's ponies. I don't need to explain anything for that. it just IS.

      ReplyDelete
    4. I thinks its because the creators and artists for the show put in a lot of effort into making it, kinda rubs off on you and gets your mind into that creative outlook

      ReplyDelete
    5. I really don't know. I used to be a writer, but over time my creativity just dwindled away till I couldn't any more. Then I stumbled across the series and, like I frequently do, I made up a character as a little gray unicorn. Then I thought of what would be a different kind of pony, and I thought 'what if there were ponies on fire.' That became the seed of Nightmare Fury and the story just swelled and grew from there. And it was more than just having a story... I had to write about it to. And the most amazing thing of all was that suddenly I could. It was like a veil had been pulled away by these wonderful dynamic characters.

      I challenged myself for the first time ever to write stories highlighting the major characters. I've got drafts of other one shots and stories. I've got my big story. I might be doing a second one for Fallout Equestria. And I love it.

      As some know I have issues with depression, and May was a bad month till I found MLP and EqD. I can honestly say that if it hadn't been for both and the many people that have made this experience rewarding, I probably wouldn't be here today.

      I don't know how and I don't know why, but I do know that I am thankful for every bit of joy I can squeeze out of it.

      ReplyDelete
    6. Creativity inspires creativity. The show itself is full of quality creativity, and it inspires more creativity, which then inspires more creativity, and so forth.

      The fact that bronydom is supportive by its nature also helps. When you're not afraid of being torn down just so someone can get their lulz, you're more likely to step forward with your own creativity. Once your creative works are out in the open, support and appreciation supply a positive reinforcement for more creativity.

      TL;DR summary: Creativity + support = more creativity.

      ReplyDelete
    7. Apart from a few reaction macros here and there I'm unfortunately not a large content creator.

      But I do dedicate hours of my time a day to enjoying others fiction/pictures/music/etc.

      The things that we have and still accomplish every day never ceases to amaze me.

      ~Scratch

      ReplyDelete
    8. I'm not sure if it's the reason behind all the content, but the simplicity of the show as a whole probably plays a big part in people's ability to create so much content.

      The lack of information about so many characters and the world as a whole means that artists and authors have a huge sandbox to explore ideas in. Combine that with the fact that the fandom already exists in a way that inspires creativity and you get a self enhancing cycle.

      Creativity begets creativity basically.

      ReplyDelete
    9. Well, this question is easy:

      1. Lauren Faust
      2. Her genuine, brilliatn and original conception (<3 ep01-2)

      Lemme just quote some of the writers from the show:

      "It was completely Lauren. And that is why I, personally, think the show has been so successful. Her vision was very clear and that is what you see in the show."

      ReplyDelete
    10. I wonder how many bronies are so because of the show or just for the sake of it (i.e. wanting to be different)
      Just a thought

      ReplyDelete
    11. It's because they're innocent. It's fun putting them in the situations they would've never been put in the show.

      ReplyDelete
    12. For me, in a very short explanation, it was how ponies exploded onto the scene as the antithesis of everything the internet had become to me.(ie Love and tolerance vs hate and grief) It's such a wonderful show that just makes me feel genuinely happy whenever I watch it.

      And I was definitely one of the many who just instantly hated people talking about ponies before I ever watched the show. I think that may have made my conversion even sweeter.

      ~Yeowzamare

      ReplyDelete
    13. Hmm. It is interesting, isn't it? Its obviously a really good cartoon. The writing, the animation, the voice acting, the songs, the characters... Its all of a quality that is way to rare these days. The last time I got this excited about a new show was Phineas and Ferb. I know The Regular Show is popular, though I never watched it.

      Still, neither of those shows quite gathered the following Friendship is Magic has. Part of it is probably the feedback we are getting. Hasbro is happy with us, a lot of the people who work on the show are happy with us, and they let us know. That is awesome. Very awesome. If you look at things, I reckon the show exploded after Feeling Pinkie Keen and the return of cross eyed Derpy. I'm sure it was popular before, but looking at the sheer amount of bronies who started watching around that time (me being one of them), that does seem to have had an impact.

      Finally, its just something about the community itself. The show makes us do what we do, but we do it. That is just as important. Without the community I doubt as many bronies would hang around during the season stop. The show made us start, but we keep it going (admittedly, I don't participate as much as others). Its a positive feedback loop.

      ReplyDelete
    14. Oddly enough I've had the exact same thing when it comes to MLP. I've tried writing before - I put out a couple things, but my interest petered out before too long. I've tried composing music. Same deal. I've tried visual art, and I met with some success and got pretty good, but even so, my heart was never in it - I never really *felt* anything, and feeling what you create as an artist is absolutely paramount. To really be a successful artist, you have to want with every fiber in your being to create, create, and create some more, and I never had that.

      That was, until MLP came along, and I started looking at fan-made movies. Something in my brain clicked at this point in time, and after doing a first trial run, I was immediately hooked. Nowadays, every single time I get home, I can't WAIT to resume work on my next pony video. The extent to which I can relate to the way in which you say "All in the name of little multi-colored marshmallow ponies" is astounding, it really is. Every time I open a project file, I always ask, "Pony videos? Really?" And the response my brain gives is "HECK YEAH PONY VIDEOS".

      I honestly, truly don't know what it is about MLP that does this to me, but I know it's something big and that it's something I've never experienced before. Maybe it's that MLP makes me feel so squishy, so warm inside, so... so GOOD that I just want the stream of pony content to never end. Maybe it's that the community is so supportive, so positive, so friendly, that I just can't help but be inspired to contribute to the greater whole. Maybe it's that the artwork is so good, and the characters so great, that it's a perfect storm of inspirational material. I don't know.

      What I *DO* know is that the MLP fandom is by far the greatest community I've ever been a part of, and I hope it continues for many, many years to come. I think there is no denying that it's something truly special and magical.

      ReplyDelete
    15. At first I wondered what the discussion was going to be about (the tags don't lie), then in the final paragraph Cereal gives us the question that can be simplified as: Why do we like ponies?

      Is it the design of the characters? The artwork? The irony? Or...does simply liking something garner enough motivation to create? Maybe it's the community that compels us to make things.

      Anyway, how should I know? I've only written a three-page fanfiction for that speedfic event.

      ReplyDelete
    16. It's really just a mix of all the components of the show working together I think to make us perceive something in its purity: something with a full range of emotions, but one above all, which is joy. A joy not seen in many other places in this world, if we're being honest. And it may be aimed initially at the young, but us older folks (age is relative, kinda) can still relate because of the basic yet profound subject matter and the way its delivered (i. e. perfectly). I could go on, but I think you get the point.
      Derpy is best pony.
      -blind2d aka Miles MacDicken

      ReplyDelete
    17. Well, I started considering being an artist for real in 5th grade when I drew my favorite cartoons, like Powerpuff Girls and Hey Arnold. Since then I've had a proper education in drawing and painting, but even now there is nothing as fun as cartooning. And what better way to build your skills and show your love for a fandom than drawing lots and lots of fanart?

      ReplyDelete
    18. Why, Cereal, DARLING, it's for the plot, naturally!

      Honestly, I think that the *massive* amounts of effort everypony puts into the fandom currently is in no small sparked by the fact that it's exciting and still relatively new, and it's fun to take part in new and exciting things with others who are just as excited as you. It's sort of a self-fulfilling prophesy, and as long as we keep the ball rolling, it's not gonna stop.

      Of course, that does nothing to explain the origins of the fanaticism that we all enjoy and partake in today, and for that... I really don't have a clue. My best guess would be that it was all catalyzed by the fact that MLP the cartoon series is a fun cartoon that doesn't take itself overly seriously and harkens back to the glory days of cartoons.

      That's just one pony's opinion, though.

      ReplyDelete
    19. Hmm... What makes us do this? Personally, I kinda think a lot of it is the show itself. It reminds me of today's Animaniacs (Still one of the best shows ever made), and it's fresh. Also, I think the overall range of topics that can be used for these ponies (Fanmade ponies, fanfiction, art, etc.) is so large that it gives people much more to do with the fandom then most others. If you asked me what my thought of this show was before I watched my first episode, I would have laughed at you and made fun of you. Now, after writing a couple fanfics, watching all the episodes (several times, might I add), making videos with ponies, and much more, I can honestly say following my curiousity was the best thing I ever did. I just want to thank the fandom and everypony who is a part of it.

      ReplyDelete
    20. I do believe the quality of the show somewhat drives the creativity of the fandom. Not to mention the world of Equestria gives artists and writers alike a open canvass to write stories and create art about it.

      I do believe that this very blog also drives people to produce the very best of the fandom.

      ReplyDelete
    21. In my opinion you have a good, friendly, critic community where you have a good start with. You dont have so many trolls or haters or anyhting who could hold you from posting any of your opinions.

      Also you got a huge world to take content of, you have a fast learning curve when drawing ponies or writing fanfic, because you have a very precise characterisation of those ponys.

      Also as said b4, there are so many helpful people out there, youll never demolished when starting something new or starting something which didnt turn out so well as you expected.

      At the same time you already got so much fiction / drawings to orientate on, to increase youre imagination and get you to write something or to get a picture i youre head which motivates you to draw something / you cant get out until you did it.

      It's simple but at the same tme it attrects beginners and experts at the same time, because you can always improve, but on the other hand with a simple thing you can get much love back.

      My thoughts WolfJoe

      ReplyDelete
    22. Speaking for myself, I'm enthralled by the potential of the universe.

      The creators have made a very interesting fantasy setting, but not really explored it. Magic exists; monsters are pulled regularly from mythology and the Dungeons & Dragons handbooks; ancient legends abound. In the interest of telling more slice-of-life stories, the writers and the cartoonists have largely left this ground fallow. If there's one thing I love, it's an undeveloped universe.

      I'm no stranger to fanfiction, having written some in the past. My ambition one day is to write my own novel series, but my ideas for that have only grown and developed over the years, and I feel they still have some growing to do before they're ready to go onto the page. In the meantime, I write fanfiction to keep myself fresh- and I've committed myself to producing it at a quality equivalent to any original work I would write. I can't in good conscience make anything else.

      As I said once in a thread on /co/, there's also a certain novelty in it for me. I've written Code Geass fanfiction, Avatar fanfiction, Transformers fanfiction, and some Gurren Lagann fanfiction. My Little Pony is my first writing universe with full-blown magic in it. I've quickly discovered it's so much fun to write stories involving magic and the curious rules it operates under. Exploring the stories that arise from a magic-filled universe has been one of the primary drivers keeping me in the Pony fanfiction game.

      Thirdly, but not least important, there's the fun of having such great characters to play around with. Like the universe itself, the main six ponies of the show have fascinating characters, but there's still areas of them left to explore. Then there are the background ponies, who are practically original characters with how much work one can put into developing them.

      The series has a great setting, a fun conceit in its magical nature, and great characters. It's a writer's dream, and I've enjoyed writing for it thoroughly.

      ReplyDelete
    23. I think that a big part of it is the fact that the world is so open, so much bigger than the show itself. We hear about locations like Fillydelphia and are able to flesh it out ourselves because they don't keep it strict. There are so many background ponies that we can write about whichever ones we like. They don't flesh out every bit of the mane cast's lives, and that allows us to put them in new situations, but they are fleshed out enough that their personalities are recognizable and writable.

      The second reason, at least to me, is the fact that this is a nice world. It's a means of escape from the reality of our lives. Yes, there are problems, but they are solved, and life goes on sweetly.

      ReplyDelete
    24. I'm a picky fellow with rather exacting standards of what constitutes "quality." Especially in cartoons. To me it seems the world of cartoons is becoming more and more subject to sturgeon's law nowadays, so when something of real quality comes out, I'll pounce on it. Even then, I've never been as involved in a fandom as I am now with these ponies. I never wrote fan-fiction, feeling that the works of others were too sacred to mess with. Part of it is the characters of the Mane 6, and part of it is the fascination that My Little Pony can be THIS GOOD to my perceptions. It's almost scary how strong this fandom is.

      ReplyDelete
    25. It's the accepting nature of the community, I think. You can draw a terrible picture, write an atrocious fanfic, make an uninpired song, and people will still find good things about it, while providing constructive criticism (instead of ridicule). By helping each other improve, and by encouraging contribution, regardless of level, everypony benefits, and everypony contributes what they can. I haven't seen a fanbase this dedicated since Golden Sun, and this is even moreso.

      TL;DR = Magic

      ReplyDelete
    26. I wrote a long response, then the Internet ate it. :/

      Short version: The whole idea of this is so silly, it's liberating. And once you feel free to explore such a world, you find it filled with near limitless creative freedom. You can make and personalize just about any kind of pony you want. It's inspirational and community-forming all in one!

      ReplyDelete
    27. You know, at first I thought it was the show. The show is amazing in and of itself, but I think the fandom practically perpetuates itself.

      Sure there's amazing art in the series. The Mario-esque happy colors definitely help. Most of all there is phenomenal writing, voice acting, and innocence...

      But that's why people come in. Not why they stay. In less than two months, I've come from being skeptical, to being a little reluctant, to checking Equestria Daily as often as I'm on my computer (which is a lot!). And here's the thing, I'm an artist in many ways. I've written a novel and painted a large picture of Luna staring from the moon. But you know what interests me more? Fanfics and music about completely insignificant ponies like Octavia, Lyra, and Ditzy. I don't know. They make me feel good and fellow bronies make me feel even better.

      Ponies for everypony! One day, I hope everyone becomes everypony and they all join the herd.

      ReplyDelete
    28. I currently have seven chapters of my first fanfic project ever up on this site. I think at least part of my desire to write it was simply wanting to have something to make the wait for season 2 less painful. Another part of it is that these characters are all just so lovable that I knew I wouldn't get tired of them if I spent all this time with them in the story I'm doing. I like plenty of other shows and universes, but I can't say I'd want to devote the kind of attention to them that a lengthy fanfic requires. Ponies are just...really fun to work with.

      ReplyDelete
    29. It was the fact that despite the odds of us EVER liking this show, (Think about it... Little brightly colored equines singing... It just attacks your gag reflex if you've never seen the show. Hell! I MADE FUN OF MLP when I was a little kid.) a massive amount of people across the globe liked it. Not only did they like it, they wanted to add something to it. And most of the people in the fandom are supportive and provide constructive critisism isnstead of troll comments and flame wars. (Heck, I've ony seen two or three true flame wars, and all of them tapered down into a logical discussion istead of escalating into a brony bloodbath)

      What I'm trying to say is, the very fact it breeds creativity breeds creativity. You feel the URGE to contribute. The desire.

      ReplyDelete
    30. I think it has something to do with how welcoming this fandom is.

      But I can't really say that for sure because I'm not one of those that have been inspired in that way.

      For me it was a little bit different. I'm usually just a lurker, I always stay in the background and just watch. But these... These ponies, this fandom, did something to me, they made me post!
      And now I'm even joining the discussions, talking about ponies! Also, I don't think anyone expected us to be talking about ponies a year ago.

      Like I said, I think this fandom just seems more welcoming and open to new members and ideas. And that's what makes this community so awesome!

      And there's so much more I want to say, but it's getting late over here and I seriously need to sleep.

      Brohoofs to all of you bronies, you are awesome!

      ReplyDelete
    31. I think it's the sincerity. No one likes the show ironically, and the fandom isn't the sort of laugh-at-the-show one that something like The Room has. It's like The Original Series of Star Trek--the fans genuinely love the show and the show genuinely loves its fans. That just engenders creativity and giving between the fans.

      ReplyDelete
    32. i don't know really.. but ponies are Awesome and cute at the same time that's very difficult to find anywhere, How is that possible!? it is for these ponies.. also the fandom is very important, if you write/draw something and is not excellent in other places people will trash your work they will only see the worst of it and lots of other things.. but here, it is different, instead of telling the worst the people talk about the best of it that, it is very inspirational and makes one want to make more and improve for the people

      ReplyDelete
    33. As someone who has a story just sent to the pre-readers, as my very first fan-fiction.

      I think what drew me to it is the fact I was able to analyze and pick apart the characters, and I found that the original writers of the show actually thought about them in-depth, enough that I could build on it. Each one has more personality than an entire cast of characters you'd find in a lot of other shows.

      It gave me something I needed, having stopped writing my own stuff months ago. It's a refreshing change from my own stuff, and it's elaborate enough already to do some cool things with.

      ReplyDelete
    34. @Mr. Jack May I say Chapter 7 was Awesome. And what you did with spike was different from my concept so we're cool now.

      ReplyDelete
    35. Im actually writing my current fan fiction right now its a Halo crossover i already submitted but it was too short and im currently working on chapter 2 and 3 right now, and ive also FILLED my deviantArt with pony pictures i find it amazing i actually took the time to do it, i never really though about it, as in why am i doing this or why i even tried because there would probably people who wouldnt like it i did it anyways. I think the reason all of of do at least ONE picture or fan fic is because when we contribute something to the brony community we feel the comfort that almost everypony will like it and appreciate what we`ve done, and give honest opinions about it, its just all the love and kindness we each receive from each other that allows us to make more contributions at least thats why i do it because i know no matter what i will always have somepony that`ll give me an encouraging comment. It`s amazing how a few months or so ago if you said anything about My Little Pony that we`d all say "Pfft...man that show is so gay." (and i mean i gotta admit G3 is pretty scary anyways) and now we come home everyday and say, "hmm wonder what i can do mabey ill keep typing up my fan fic." or "gotta, finish that pony pic man, gunna be epic :)" i think its amazing how these ponies are bringing out the best of ourselves and how they give so much encouragement to each and every one of us, which we give to each other, to make this incredible fan base, and thats what this is all about Friendship, Friendship. Is. Magic. Never forget that. I love this show, this fanbase, and my fellow bronies, despite what anypony says we`re just like one big pony family :D

      ReplyDelete
    36. Well, I believe it has something to do with the community. Everypony is very accepting and supportive of the things other people contribute. The fact that they aren't being criticized for their work drives more people to write, draw, make games, and even get together and have fan made conventions.

      ReplyDelete
    37. I feel the creativity that went into making the show. These days, we really don't get shows made like this anymore. It's all reality and other crap. The inspiration comes from how fresh it is and also because the cast is very relatable. We all know someone who has qualities of Fluttershy or Rainbow Dash.

      ReplyDelete
    38. Also, I just had a thought. In most other fandoms where the audience is more "proper" (e.g., young men being fans of Modern Warfare), there's still a facade of social acceptability that causes people to put up pretenses, and think, "What would people think if I did this? They'd probably think I was a loser. I'd better not." This is the sort of thing that almost everyone finds themselves in to at least one degree or another on a daily basis, and can be an absolute boot to the throat of creativity.

      Here, though? We're young men who are fans of My Little Pony. If a thought creeps up along the lines of, "What would people think if I did this?", the brain can then immediately respond, "They already know you watch MY LITTLE PONY for heaven's sake; how bad could it be?" As such, all facades are lifted and fans can just be exactly who they are and who they want to be. I think that utter lack of pretense undoubtedly leads to at least a portion of the positivity and creativity in the MLP fandom.

      ReplyDelete
    39. Latham HendricksonJuly 7, 2011 at 7:25 PM

      I think that because the show is so non-cynicle people find themselves more confident in thier artistic works when they think about it, allowing thier tallent to flower in its form. I hope that made sense.

      ReplyDelete
    40. I was writing fan fiction for a good while before I joined this fandom, and the best explanation I have for why I love creating new fanfics for ponies is the same one I came up with for why I started writing fanfics for The Lion King: I wanted to see more of these characters. In a way, I'm like Lauren Faust; when I was a little kid, there were no boundaries between what I imagined and what my toys could do. Even when I was just a little kid, anything I obsessed over was taken to astronomically excessive lengths inside my head. I'll never forget the multi-movie-length-portion Frogger/Pokemon crossover that fully occupied the space between my ears for, oh, four years or so. Looking back on it, it's almost hilariously stupid, but I was utterly addicted to both games so much that I wanted to do my own thing with them. I wanted more of something I couldn't have, so I let my imagination fill in that gap for me.

      I haven't grown out of that tendency yet; I just use fan fiction as my outlet, and as my training for the career as a professional novelist I hope to have someday. To be honest, I hope I never grow out of it, because that's where I get all my inspiration from; the YA novel series I plan on writing someday evolved from what was once a poorly planned and (self-described) "better" sequel to The Incredibles. Bringing this big ol' mess of tl;dr back around to ponies, the magic of the show for me personally is the ability of the characters to, for whatever reason, inspire that kind of imaginative creativity in me on a daily basis.

      I've always been a sucker for animated movies and shows, and FiM absolutely fits the one requirement that I have in order to be inspired by anything enough to write about it: it has engaging characters whose deeper personalities, due to time constraints or simple oversight or any number of other reasons, are left open to interpretation. That's why I write for MLP: I want to see what these characters would do in situations that the show would never touch on. I want to see Twilight would handle the stress of a wartime scenario. I want to see what would happen if Rainbow Dash were forced to choose between saving her friends and keeping the most integral part of her identity. I want to see what would happen if Vinyl Scratch fell in love with Dash and helped her discover her own feelings by coaching her to sing "Fat Bottomed Girls" in an Equestria-wide singing contest.

      But most of all, I just want to see more of the characters I've come to know and love. When I run out of episodes to watch and other stories and pictures to look at, I take that as meaning it's time to share my own thoughts.

      tl;dr confound these ponies, they drive me to write.

      ReplyDelete
    41. Interesting question. I'm a biologist, and I read in a book that humans are drawn to things with estilyzed shapes and big, round eyes (Babies are the easier example). But that alone does not explains the why. People claim it's the plot, other says it's the drawings or the animation. I consider it is that the story transmit something so simple that some of us forget in our daily lifes. Friendship.

      I don't know you guys, but I feel like a kid whenever I sit and watch MLP, that's just a personal appreaciation. However, when I watch it, something triggers in me: "I want you to go to your notebook and write a novel that seven hundred pages long, or draw rarity in a new pose". Why? Because there's got to be more to them other than just the boundaries placed in the series, and the characters, the location and everything in the MLP universe is practically begging to be extended or mixed with anything.

      I think MLP FiM and its Fandom are amazing; at first i felt bad for watching the show, but now I feel like there is nothing wrong with it and changed my FB profile pic to a pony. Now I'm taking long, I'll close by saying that this universe, the my little pony universe, offers infinite possibilities to all sorts of artists out there.

      ReplyDelete
    42. Personally...

      I think one of the reasons I love this so much is because of the fandom. Not saying the show itself isn't awesome, because it is (and if you think otherwise, why are you here?)

      Somehwere along the line, some dude thought "Hey, this is awesome, and I don't care what people say." Then he told a friend. His friend would've been shy about liking it openly, but with his friend, (the Proto-Brony as it were) he had someone to stand with. They told others. and then they told others.

      We have strength in numbers, and with that comes confidance, and with confidiance, we can love this show all the more, online and off. And the more we love it, the more we gather new people.

      How many of you have said when trying to convince someone to watch it, "Tons of people love it!" or the equivalent? Humankind is a social species, averse to breaking from the pack, but when a group DOES break from the pack, they have the opportunity to become something beyond anything the world has ever seen.

      And call me crazy, but that's what we've done.

      ReplyDelete
    43. I don't know about everyone else, but I know that my personal reasons don't really make much sense. I fell in love with a quirky cartoon show and decided that I wanted to draw some pony fanart and found it ridiculously easy for some reason.

      It's fun and innocent and cute and I enjoy knowing that my personal style meshes so well with canon pony art. It gives me something to pour my efforts into and know that the internet will praise me for it because the MLP:FiM community is so welcoming and positive. : )

      ReplyDelete
    44. Fanfiction was a hobby of mine well before the multicolored ponies came around. Ever hear of Starwing HQ? I was someone on that site--it was fanfiction from across the video game universe, and I was young enough at the time to love everything I read. I couldn't get enough! But sadly, real life intervened on behalf of the updating admin, and drama helped the site into decline and all but death.
      Then I moved to Gaia and took part in Fire Emblem roleplays... but as before, real life and drama. Only not so much drama. I still hang out with a core group of people who split from that FE guild, but the most we do know is chat on AIM. And real life has yet again dwindled our numbers.
      For a time, I wondered if this might be the end... but then ze ponies appeared! And they were all "DUDE, LIKE, WE'RE TOTALLY DEEP CHARACTERS AND STUFF" and Equestria was all "DUDE, LIKE, I'M SO BIG, AND THERE'S LOADS OF ADVENTURE STILL TO BE HAD" and the monsters were all "DUDE, I'M A MANTICORE! AND I'M A GIANT COSMIC BEAR, HOW COOL IS THAT!?"

      AND SO, RISEN FROM THE ASHES LIKE A FREAK PONY PHOENIX, RECAMEN THE FANFICTIONEER WAS REBORN!

      So, time to continue Ch. 11--one awesome bit with Octavia down, one awesome duet with Luna and Rarity to go.

      ReplyDelete
    45. We saw a show that would never be accepted as entertainment, transformed, made watchable, by one of our childhood idols.

      Ponies is everything that the world could become, if we only put a little effort into it, together.

      ReplyDelete
    46. Bottom line is; when people contribute to the community, they feel good. Moreso than in other fanbases. This has at least two causes:

      >The show set an example for creativity and enthusiasm. You can tell just by watching it that the team that created it had fun with it.

      >The fanbase, unlike many others, truly takes to heart the lessons of the show, which allows for a supportive and collaborative environment.

      Everything about how this fanbase is structured seems to promote synergy and productivity. I'd need to think more to come up with specific examples.

      ReplyDelete
    47. Being a just-starting pony writer myself (actually, I'm writing this post during a break in writing what I hope to be my first submitted work) I too find myself enraptured by the ponyfolk in a way nothing else has before. It's surprisingly refreshing.

      ReplyDelete
    48. I've actually seen this occur in the WALL-E fandom as well. Granted, that was more of an offshoot of the WALL-E forum role play, but...

      ReplyDelete
    49. It was said near the beginning of the discussion that creativity inspires creativity. I say this is as valid an explanation as exists out there. The show itself showcases the creativity of Lauren Faust and her team, and that inspired the community, which started an avalanche.
      I've been a part of two big communities: LG15, and MLP. Back in my days watching LG15, I already considered myself an experienced writer, but that show and its community inspired me to do something I'd never tried before: Roleplay. The official forums had a section for in-universe roleplay, and, inexplicably, I joined.
      Now, MLP promises to lead me to do similar things. I have my own original characters, something I never would have previously considered for a cartoon, of all things. I've done a few drawings, and I'm considering fanfic... I can't explain it... It's just happening.

      So yeah. Creativity inspires creativity. I'm sticking with that.

      ReplyDelete
    50. Ah, Cereal. That is a question for the ages, no doubts. Why do we, as the men and women, children and adults, of this fandom produce so much content? Why do we, as a collective group of like-minded individuals come up with all the art, stories, music, and the likes for these multi-colored marshmallows, to borrow your term? Simple, really: It's because we love it.

      From the perspective of some tallentless hack who's been writing stories since they were ten, and who's been imagining crazy crossover scenarios since well before that, it really is because we love the works we create for the fandom, and that everyone else loves it as well. We support each other's works, comment on it, share it with others, favorite it.

      Why exactly do we do that though? Because we've been given a genuinely happy world with so much left undiscovered, and we enjoy letting others discover and show it to us and revel in its joy together.

      Basically, what I think I'm trying to say, is that Faust and the rest of the team gave us this world full of wonders, left it half empty and with many secrets behind it, and we're simply populating it and discovering those secrets. It's sort of natural to want to know "Oh, how does this character fit in?" or "Oh, what happened to that character?" or even "Where did this character come from?" We've only been given a small portion, and we want to fill in all the large holes.


      But yeah, the show captures us with its amazing imagery, colorful world, and lovable characters. I think I lost the rest of what I was saying somewhere and just started rambling, so I think I'll be quiet and let others explain it better than I can.

      ReplyDelete
    51. I havn't contributed to the community at all (yet...) so I probablly don't get a real say in this, but if you ask me I think it has to do with what Lauren Faust accomplished to acheive and show with this cartoon, she took something that literaly had next to no real backstory and generally shallow characters that not a lot of people would care about and acctually made it into something fantastic, making something from nearly nothing, and managing to attract a massive adult male audience for something originally designed for girls, and that talent has inspired countless fans to create beautiful works of fan art and deep, engaging fanficions of many genres, where the most well known is pretty out of place when you consider what franchise it is based on, and even taking certain background characters and giving them full personalitys that are as diverse as the mane cast, in short Lauren created something fantastic and we loved it too much to not make our own content for it.

      ReplyDelete
    52. What I've liked about other fandoms I have and have been involved in is that there was always something talk about, which is why I liked certain video game, movie, live-action television, and other serial media communities, but never found my place in discussing cartoons. I find now that the main reason why was simply because there was nothing to discuss beyond perhaps a "DID YOU SEE HOW MUCH OF A BUFFOON HE WAS TODAY" and maybe a reaction image screencap. With Frendship is Magic and bronies, even though only 26 episodes of the series have aired (a relatively small number and combined running time compared to the other television shows and movie franchises which have obtained a massive fan following), people always seem to draw something out of it to make new threads and host new discussions.

      Friendship is Magic makes speculations, essays, fanart and comics, and fanfiction all the more FUN -- and that's the determining factor, just how entertaining the fanfiction, fanart, and video edits can be -- to create, read, and observe because people are charmed by and care about what it offers: a world which sets just enough of a blueprint to be recognizable from afar, yet still includes enough ambiguity balancing the insight and dimensions placed in its characters and universe to allow these aspects to be interpreted in a variety of ways. It's this variety of interpretations which makes the fandom feel so alive and consistently fresh, even between seasons.

      ReplyDelete
    53. I think its a couple of things.

      Firstly, there is the *depth* of the world that the show's creators have broadly defined but (by comparison) barely explored. We have an entire world full of stories waiting to be told and just enough primers to start telling them! No matter the setting, that is very ripe ground for creative endeavors.

      Secondly, we have a community that wants to hear those stories even as we tell them. When one of us decides to make a sketch with our favorite character in a silly / sad / touching / or everyday slice-of-life moment, the rest of us see it and go 'Oh! I want more!' Someone else follows it up with a story, another brony composes a musical score from the inspiration, and that music / story inspire more visual arts. As a poster above me said "Creativity begets creativity".

      Finally, we as a creative community, have gone out of our way to be inclusive. We welcome, cherish and encourage new talent. We (generally) do not mock, or otherwise scorn, 'beginner' level work. Rather, we strongly encourage said creators to keep creating, even if their work isn't 'professional' - because the act of creation, and the open willingness to share, is of paramount importance to us. We do offer criticism and advice, but out of a spirit of kindness, not malice. As a community, that kind of inclusiveness and positivity is rare. As a community formed and founded almost entirely online, it's nigh unheard of!

      So, yeah. Take a great show that leaves the creative mind with an entire world to play in, a community of fans that all leap at the chance to see more of said world and are decent people, willing to encourage even the 'least' of us to open just one more window into Equestria, and you have a perfect recipe for a creative storm of the decade!

      ReplyDelete
    54. Bridled Fury is my first successful work in ages. I'd hung up my writing for months, only recently dusting it off to give it a go. My recent dive into pony sketches hasn't been without its troubles (drawing Pinkie's hair is HARD), but it's worth it. This is the first time I've ever considered myself a big fan of something, and by God did I choose the right group to join.

      ReplyDelete
    55. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 7:51 PM

      Seriously? Can we stop acting like this show is more than it actually is? It's not some wonderful life changing thing, it doesn't make you more creative, it just a show, for girls no less. Can people stop acting pretentious about this show?

      ReplyDelete
    56. I had just gotten back from Afghanistan in March, completing my third year in the middle east. I hadn't heard a thing about the My Little Pony rebirth, in fact I wouldn't hear anything about it until late May; instead, I was having a hard time re-acclimating myself to the "real world" again.
      First world complaints infuriated me, I was troubled slightly by my experiences, and I couldn't find anything I wanted to do. All the video games where an attempt to realize war for 12 year old children, books where being read, but with little zeal, and TV was (and mostly still is) a jumble of horrid reality shows. I was pathetically adrift, wallowing in whatever it is ponies wallow in.
      I first caught a glimpse of the new ponies in a profile image on facebook (which I spent very little time on). I recognized the MLP shape, but the form was new and unfamiliar. So I delved into the net and was sucker punched by the shear volume of what I encountered. I watched my first episode after season one ended (to which I owe masterlinkx a great debt of gratitude) and I did something I hadn't done in... well at that point a long time. I giggled.
      Then I watched some more. That first night I watched the entire first season, laughing myself to tears. I slipped back online and over the next few days finding EQDaily and lurked, immersing myself in the fandom.
      You ponies are amazing. The creativity, the ability, the kindness. It cracked a shell I hadn't even realized I had erected about me. On day 19, of the Artist Training Grounds, I began submitting work. I was drawing ponies, and still am quite regularly.
      I'm a fan because the show is quality, the characters are engaging, bronies are amazing, and together it gave me pause to catch my breath.
      Though I admit, these are only my personal reasons, each bronie is different.
      Laughter is a virtue. Honesty, kindness, loyalty and generosity should never go unrecognized. And friendship.... friendship really is magic.

      ReplyDelete
    57. Ah, a truly challenging question. What is it about ponies that has attracted so many young men and women of all creeds, backgrounds, and personalities? What is it that drew me in, a 19 year old male whose idea for fun is to don armor, beat the crap out of friends, then watch comedy movies and listen to metal songs about death, love, pain, honor, and glory?

      I suppose, for me, it is beauty. Peace. Innocence. I have found, in the land of these colorful little equines, a redeeming sense of innocence that can not be tainted, no matter how hard the internet tries. Like many kids my age, I've been disillusioned to reality, and the fact that I can't be a true hero or go on adventures is... crushing. My innocence was blindly thrown away, for this world that is not what is was supposed to be.

      So when, 4 months ago, I returned to Funnyjunk to our favorite girls filling the comments section, I was confused. What on earth are these things? And why are they so bloody funny? What is it about this pink one saying "I'll be waiting for you upstairs." or this little yellow one cringing that enthralls me so? It can't be my furry background, that's a well understood part of me. What is it? Right there, started my indoctrination. I slowly worked up the courage to watch an episode, joking with a friend who was next to me, before closing it a few minutes in. I went back the next day. And the next day.

      Now that I have had time to dwell upon what brought me here, it is my understanding that comedy and well designed memes brought me to this place. A great show gave me new entertainment. Then I examined all of those people who had been posting the ponies. And I found a family.

      So what that long, disjointed, and half-thought out story says is that, when it comes down to it, I'm here because of you guys. You bronies, your brother in peace, you Colts and Mares. Every new story, every image, every fanfiction, every indoctrination tale, every single real moment with this herd, is joyous and blissful. I have, hands-down, never been as cumulatively happy as I have during my time in the herd.

      Never have I been so willing to bleed for a stranger, to defend the put-upon, to stand up for peace, than when I joined the herd. And when I did that, I took an oath that many of us have heard time and time again.

      Love and Tolerance. For everyone. Always.

      I love each and every one of you, no matter what. We are in this together, and forever we are a family.
      -Silver Mane, Brony.
      T. McNicol

      (I basically broke each paragraph before it turned into a 3-page essay. Fanfics alone could have kept me going for an hour)

      ReplyDelete
    58. Old Jewish proverb: "When eating pork, let the grease dribble down your neck." Meaning that if you're going to indulge in something 'wrong', you might as well enjoy yourself and not hold back.

      When people draw ponies, they know on some level that they're never going to have it taken seriously, so that give them the freedom to put even more energy and creative exploration in ponies than in the works that are meant to be 'taken seriously.'

      When people start out with that thought; 'that it doesn't matter', it removes the fear of failure. Suddenly, they are emotionally and creatively venerable, (something that is extremely hard to do in art of any sort), because they know there will be no repercussions for doing so.

      They spend the next day/week/month pouring their heart into something because they enjoy because, they feel protected by that idea of it 'not mattering'.
      With the stuff thats 'suppose to matter', the artist often more concerned with what others will think about the work, not what the artist themselves think and feel and want for the piece.

      So they get into a safe place doing 'wrong' art (as if there is a correct way to do art), and THEN... they get feed-back.

      They see a huge part of their creative energy, ideas, personal philosophies, and even their artistic soul, ENJOYED by others. Others who are able to feel the emotions that the artists put into the drawing, and send their own emotions back to the artists in the form of comments, critiques, and praises.

      And fuck-me is that feedback addictive.

      Next thing you know, you're like mad max and you've drawn 1500 comics, or are like one of the writers who have already written 80 pages of pure pony.

      See the only barometer that matters is your own, and the one you can ever truly create for is yourself. Thats the only way you can grow as an artist is to challenge yourself with content and ideas, not limit your self to what art is 'suppose to be.'

      Yet, most people never get the chance to be vulnerable in that manner. But ponies man, they somehow give you that feeling of freedom. That, hell, since your doing something that a man/artist/adult is not suppose to do, then you might as well indulge.

      And thats how equestira was made.

      ReplyDelete
    59. I haven't written anything since probably 2002. Before that, I wrote stories to amuse myself, using original characters and settings. It was an outlet. I needed to create and writing was the one thing I was halfway decent at. I stopped writing because I had no more stories to tell.

      These pastel ponies have inspired me to write something I've never done before: Fan Fiction. Why would I use someone else characters and idea to build a story when i could create my own? The answer is simple: The crew of skilled writers, animators, and musicians created such a beautiful world, the artist inside me felt compelled to bring more of it to life.

      Art inspires art, and ponies inspire greatness. Just looking at the quilt of talented writers, artists, and musicians inspires me to create my own piece of the cloth.

      I love My Little Ponies, and not just because of the show. The fandom has inspired me to create again, reawakening the hobby that I once loved so much. For that, I can't thank them enough.

      ReplyDelete
    60. It's the ideology. The show seems to say: Fun is fun, you don't have to be a pretentious twonk. You don't have to be embarrassed because something cute made you chuckle. So what if it's pink? So what if it's fluffy? So what if it's about rainbow colored flying ponies!? Fun is fun. Get over yourself and just share a laugh!

      The fandom is brimming with irreverence toward social norms. Not in a shallow, cynical way but in a light-hearted, self-confident, I-can-laugh-at-myself kinda way.

      It's strange. In some way the adoration of these ponies is one of the most /grown up/ things I've seen on the Internet in years.

      ReplyDelete
    61. I used to write.

      And then stuff happened and for about a decade I no longer could. My well had run dry.

      And now I write and I draw. Ponies. Not particularly well mind you. But that isn't important. The point is that I do.

      Is the difference that I care about something now? That it's okay for me to love something? That it's suddenly okay to feel or hope or believe?

      I don't know. I can't explain it. I've really tried.

      ReplyDelete
    62. I don't know why, myself. I've never written a song from scratch before ponies. In fact, I've never recorded anything before. It's a mystery, is what it is.

      ReplyDelete
    63. For me, I think it's the depth of the world and characters that draws me in. Even the background ponies are given these incredible backstories and personalities by other fans. There's a lot of different possibilities for fan art/fiction. It also opens a new dimension for crossovers and the like.

      ReplyDelete
    64. As Boserup said: "Necessity is the mother if invention."

      Now, you may be thinking "Krypqe, don't be a silly filly; ponies aren't necessary to our lives..."

      But is that really the truth? Look at who you are now; the person you exist as.
      Now, look at that person, but without pony influence.

      Are they the same person? I have a feeling the answer would be "no."

      What I'm saying is: These ponies have changed us, even if you choose not to believe it, or just havn't noticed yet. They've become a part of us, that's how special this whole fandom is.

      Ponies are a part of us, they're necessary for us to exist, if we wish to continue existing how we are.

      Thus, this necessity we all carry needs to be satisfied, yet the satisfaction is not just in the recieving/appreciation of Pony things, but also in the creation. After all, does the show not tell us to please our friends, not just ourselves?

      ReplyDelete
    65. The large fandom, as well as the show, has inspired me in many ways.

      For once, I'm actually drawing again, mostly thanks to the NATGs. And through drawing ponies, it's helped me work on my style of drawing(eye shapes, facial expressions, and posing for one). I really need to get a DeviantART account or something, I just wish I wasn't so damn shy about showing my work. Aside from drawn art, I'm currently working on an amigurumi Spike, so I hope that turns out well.

      I never thought this would happen, but ponies inspired me to start singing! The show's songs have such a Disney charm to them, I can't help but break out randomly into one of the shows' songs! I can't sing great, but hey, it's something!

      The endless fan output for this fandom is really mind-blowing. People that take time to dedicate what creativity they have for this show is truly inspiring to its extreme. That's what makes me so happy to be a part of this fandom, even though I'm pretty much a ghost at times, I'll admit. That's something I need to work on...gotta stop being shy! >.<

      ReplyDelete
    66. I got into the show because my kids liked it. I watch it with them. It's a good show, regardless of target demographic.

      My wife was feeling tired and grouchy the other day. I youtubed up "Swarm of the Century," and soon she was into it. It cheered her up. She laughed at the one-pony-band reveal.

      I make art based on the show because my kids like it, and also because I like to think the show's creators can see it, somewhere, and feel pride.

      ReplyDelete
    67. Rule 20%: if it exists, there is a pony of it.

      ReplyDelete
    68. My main reason for liking it would have to be just the pure irony of it all. How something so seemingly innocent could become something like this. It was my own curiosity that originally got me into liking this show too. I always liked trying new things, and this got me really interested at first. I never really saw myself as liking something like this, but ive learned over time to never try and determine where you will be in the near or distant future, things have a funny way of changing all the time.

      ReplyDelete
    69. For me, this fandom has really brought out my creativity. Before I discovered, the only type of feedback I got on my writing and artwork was from my friends. I never really decided to show it on the internet, and when I did, it didn't really garner much attention.
      Then this came along. I've found myself trying many new and creative things lately. Hell, I just put a Sculpey Harry Potter pony in the oven.

      ReplyDelete
    70. What made me start writing fanfiction?

      For me, it was the community.

      My story sounds a lot like Cereal's. I'd attempted to write novel-length stories before, but I always gave up early on. (The furthest I ever got was 50 pages, double spaced. World Without Rainbows is already twice as long as that, plus an additional 20% or so.)

      The difference between the two stories is obvious. The one I tried to write before was only seen by a few other people, most of whom honestly didn't care one way or the other. And no feedback meant no motivation to keep writing.

      Jump to a bit closer to the present. It's because of the community that WWR exists at all; I was reading comments on the Cutie Mark Chronicles discussion post, and a conversation starts up about what the mane 6 would be like if the first Sonic Rainboom had never happened. I think, okay, why not, I'll give it a try.

      I had no idea so many bronies kept tabs on this site. I got lots of positive encouragement from the first few chapters, and I kept writing.

      The reason why there's so much art is, put simply, because there's always an audience for it. And because everyone is so welcoming, you're encouraged to get out there and share what you've created.

      Someone (I forget who) said that Friendship is Magic isn't a fandom, it's a subculture. I completely agree. People see and want to contribute to this growing mass of fleshy ponies.

      And it is awesome.

      ReplyDelete
    71. I'm a terrible writer.
      A terrible artist.
      A weak musician.
      Uncreative. Untalented. A blank flank.

      Sounds depressing, but it isn't- I just can't contribute.

      ReplyDelete
    72. The welcoming atmosphere of the fandom in general is certainly a key part. There's no feeling of having to be a superstar right out of the gate or needing to churn out tons of smutty stuff just to get noticed.

      The sheer scope of creativity plays a major part in it too, I think. It's not just limited to drawing pictures or writing stories; we've also had sculptures, customized figures, papercraft figures, handmade plushes, giant Minecraft murals, songs, animations, tons of mods and made from scratch video games, lots of other stuff I can't think of off the top of my head... practically every possible creative outlet has seen something pony-related come from it. It's hard to not want to jump in somehow when you see just how truly widespread it's become.

      ReplyDelete
    73. While I haven't written any fanfiction, I do a bit of writing and drawing. My primary goal, aside from releasing these blasted creative energies, is to share the things I create with people who appreciate them.

      I participated in the Newbie Artist Training Grounds event, submitting an entry every single day. Every comment I got just made me want to try harder, to top the previous entry. In this fandom, many will appreciate what you create, and I think that lends to the creative spirit revolving around it.

      On the other hand, or hoof, ponies are charming, colorful, and fun to draw. I tried drawing people again during the event, and after the event concluded. Somehow, they didn't feel nearly as flexible as ponies. Perhaps it's because ponies don't contain my drawing weaknesses: hands, feet, and clothing folds.

      Anyways, that's my two minor currency units.

      ReplyDelete
    74. It's magic.

      I ain't gotta explain shit.

      ReplyDelete
    75. The characters of the series are so...lovable. Each and every one. That is the main reason, I believe. No other series, be it TV, video game, movie, whatever, has had such a strong cast of loveable characters.

      Also, I discovered ponies on /v/ believe it or not, after spotting several anon's using pony reaction images.

      ReplyDelete
    76. What I believe makes people, or at least me, put whatever it is that we do out there is the community itself and in a smaller, but still large way, Equestria Daily.

      I can't say that I searched as thoroughly as some people, but I haven't seen any other fan sites that have gone above and beyond for a single show. There's many websites that are quite massive and with a big following, but none that have been made exclusively for a single fan base.

      With the pony community, this allows for the daily dose of pony news in constant different ways whether it's a new plushie, merchandise locations, episode/season updates, or fanfiction/art. With other sites it's a hit and miss when you see something of the genre that interests you, but there's a tendency to scroll over those that don't.

      As the first example off the top of my head, Halolz posts video's and pictures up, but it is somewhat often that I won't really get the reference and don't know the game it's from so I just move on. With equestria daily, the more likely reason people pass up news is when a certain post is irrelevant to their interests instead of not knowing what it's about. It's ALL ABOUT PONIES.

      The community is the other large selling point for dipping your feet in the water. The community is by far the most responsive and nice community I've seen. I'm not saying we're completely rainbows and lollipops, but the parasprites are few and far between. Having attempted my second attempt at a story ever "Twilight Sparkle: Mare Attorney" and getting the feedback from not just the site itself thanks to pre-readers but from the readers itself makes things seem a whole lot more responsive.

      Either way, I'm just glad that I've found this community. My love for these marshmallow ponies isn't going anywhere.

      ReplyDelete
    77. I've written before for the Chip 'n Dale Rescue Ranger fandom (which until now was the only fandom I was apart of) and that was the first I had *ever* done anything so creative. It was great, the fandom (at least on The Acorn Cafe) is very much like what I've seen here: supportive, helpful, creative, and all-round fun. It's amazingly refreshing to see this sort of thing and often times you get to make a lot of new friends out of it. I know the CDRR fandom has been around for about 15 years now, and I dearly hope that this fandom will stick around for at least as long.

      Thank you to all of those running this site and all the other fan sites.

      ReplyDelete
    78. Ponies inspire creativity because of the sensation you get from watching the show, and then realizing what it is you're watching. Not only are you watching MY LITTLE PONY and NOT crying out for mercy/begging for death, but are actually ENTHRALLED and COMPELLED by these loveable and believable personalities which come to you in a form you never knew you wanted to experience.

      Once you have shattered the barrier that separates "age/gender marketing" and "enjoyment of pure innocence", your mind is consumed by the joy that can only come from knowing you are open-minded enough to watch a show that will get you laughed at, and to know that it is those who will laugh at you who are, in fact, wrong. And through this joy you will embrace it and do whatever it is to express yourself and speak your mind, breaking your limits and doing what you never thought you would. For most, this involves creativity. For others, research and presentation. For others still, the will to express oneself awakens in building such a magnificent site as EQDaily, where all the others may come together and share the fruits of their common interest.

      ReplyDelete
    79. Now I don't write about ponies and probably never will, but this show probably changed my life. Before this show came along I wanted to be an artist. I wanted to start my own webcomic and create my own story. Right before ponies came along I had just started using adobe illustrater but only rarely. As soon as I had found ponies my art skills skyrocketed and now I'm taking art classes at the academy of art university.
      I really think that if it wasn't for ponies and the creativity of this fandom and its motivation I would never have become the passionate artist I am now.

      ReplyDelete
    80. Maybe because when ponies saw that something as lame as My Little Pony looked so awesome as Friendship is Magic, ponies became confident and began to hone their skills to do stuff. IDK.

      ReplyDelete
    81. I'm chalking this up to the fanbase. I've been around a lot of internet communities, and they all have the same bitterness in common. Elitism and a disturbing pride in how inaccessible they are. I hardly got along because everybody was so surly and it felt like a single misstep could result in getting ostracized... as it had happened before.

      Yeowzamare said it best. Because of the nature of the source material, bronydom IS the best online community to join and hang out. The flavor of the internet seems to be bitterness and sarcasm, which I always thought I must have been a freak to not embrace. Not only do we subscribe to the ways of love and tolerance, but we actually MEAN it.

      The best part is that if you are the type of person who would enjoy the show, you sacrifice nothing in becoming part of the community. Everybody is sincere. Everybody is nice. Everybody is willing to give the benefit of a doubt. There's no internet egos flying around and there's no trying to impress a scant elite to try and be somebody. You don't have to jump through flaming hoops or squirm through a keyhole to be considered one of the fandom. You just... are. In other fandoms, you'd get ridiculed if you didn't know X detail. In this fandom, we wait patiently for a person to get caught up just so we can see their reaction.

      I've been joining communities and writing fiction all my life (both fan and original). I'm just a little wary sharing it because there's too much competition or comparison out there. On the internet, the initial response is to accentuate the negative, find the failings. I'm constantly trying to improve my writing style, but sometimes I just want to be creative and write and entertain people with my words.

      I've been forced out of communities with selfish hostility disguised as tough love. I had then associated my love for writing with an invitation to be put down. Here, however, I KNOW that what I have to write will be seen and enjoyed by many. There's some criticism in the mix, but it's presented in such a way that I get the impression that it's said for the good of all involved and at the expense of none. My writing, both for work and pleasure, has never flourished more.

      Lastly but certainly not least, the show itself is just so rich in culture. It's a fantasy world that deconstructs as many sugary sweet cartoon cliches as it plays straight... sometimes doing one and then the other in straight succession. Everything feels relevant and I'm pretty sure that someday, a brony will break down Ponyville's economic flow... if not all of Equestria's. The ponies do such cool things as race to shake down leaves or just outright HELP A SEASON ON ITS WAY OUT, and then do such mundane-yet-practical things as removing tree branches to prepare for a storm... that they themselves SCHEDULED.

      Okay, I lied about that 'lastly.' The characters are all three-dimensional and have very real hopes, aspirations, and distinct personalities. Not only are they distinct, but they are enjoyable! Every character COULD be boiled down to simple stereotypes and played through for all they're worth, but the writing is so solid and varied that you can't tell what can happen next or what could be said.

      Here's an example: In Bridle Gossip, Rarity's curse is her mane and coat getting frazzled beyond any hope of conventional fashion. You'd expect, then, to hear her rag on and on and on about it all through the episode. I was surprised to see a minimal amount of that. The true moment this shined through was when Pinkie was claiming Zecora took her song, and Rarity said very genuinely, "She stole your song?" Rarity very easily put aside her own troubles to notice Pinkie's relatively trivial claim, and be sincere in her asking.

      ReplyDelete
    82. This show has brought me fun and joy, oddly enough I wouldn't think that I could actually reference things such as 20% cooler to my friends relating to a pony show. This show has so much to offer, the creativity, even the community. Bronys one and all are so awesome to each other, its essentially peace here in Equestria. I LOVE IT!!!! : 3

      ReplyDelete
    83. (Continued due to character limitations. If you've read this far, what's another two paragraphs?)

      This show is just so well written, animated, and otherwise realized that I NEED to show my appreciation. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, so... fan fiction. And since video games are the goggles I occasionally wear when viewing the world, it is my highest honor to mix this source material with the games I hold so dear.

      So... thank you Laurent Faust, Studio B, Hasbro for going along with it, the Hub and especially everybrony here. I had the world pegged as a place increasingly devoid of risks and basic compassion. Not any more.

      Whew. That's a wall of text. Who read all this? :D

      ReplyDelete
    84. Many things, I suppose, inspire me to make my contributions to the fanbase, but I think they can be tossed into four specific groups:

      Things I'd been meaning to learn to do but had been putting off (I'd been wanting to learn how to make videos of some sort for forever, though I never made ANY headway in learning how video editing software worked),

      Seeing the astonishing variety of content the fans had been producing and so thoroughly embracing (meaning that I felt I was in the minority by not contributing and that whatever I could do would be at very least appreciated),

      The amazing variety of content in only the first season of the show (I started thinking of things that would be amazing for PMVs and thought "WHY HAS NOPONY MADE THIS YET?". I still have a couple like that on my list),

      And the one I'm admittedly a tad ashamed of, knowing I could do better than some of the people out there. A few times I've thought "come on, is that all you've got? Lemme show you how it's done." Most of the time I don't actually act on it, but I've gotten fairly far in the process of trying to make better versions of other people's works before. And from this spawned perhaps my most widespread video, "Pinkazoid! TV Intro".

      So I suppose it's a giant mixture that drives us all. The ponies themselves and the fantastic amount of content and love put into every aspect of the show's creation, us seeing the fantastic amount of content and support coming from and going into this fanbase, and our competitive natures to try to prove our all.


      That and the fact that unless we've got a weird birthmark or an ass-tattoo, we're all still trying to discover our special talents.

      ReplyDelete
    85. For me, the inspiration for the (admittedly poor) doodles and (admittedly worse) fanfiction I've written about MLP has come from two things: the community and the characters in the show.

      To clarify the first part, the community already has so much creativity floating around, that it just makes me want to add to it, even if what I do isn't on the same level as those who I get my inspiration from.

      Also, me saying that I get inspiration from the characters probably seems like a "duh" statement. What I really meant there is that the characters themselves lend so much to new creations. They are archetypes that, while well defined as individuals, can still be used to achieve any number of things story-wise without having to break their character to do so. This makes writing something a lot easier and makes the process more enjoyable.

      TL;DR- The brony community makes you want to give, whilst the show provides an easy and fun base to build off of.

      ReplyDelete
    86. I think it is simply that these little marshmallow ponies are more real and thought out and portrayed with true feelings and flaws then all of the crap characters that Hollywood seems to have a hard on for putting on the screen. These little ponies I would love to have as friends and that above all makes them very special.

      ReplyDelete
    87. There is just something about ponies. They go with everything.

      The new cartoon is part of it, but the appeal goes beyond that--for years customizers have been making pony customs of characters from everything you can think of--Star Wars, Power Rangers, Spider-Man, Harry Potter, Corpse Bride, Labyrinth--if you can think of it, there has been a pony custom and pony art made of it. AND THEY ALL WORK. It wouldn't with Barbie or He-Man, but ponies? Hell yeah.

      Ditto with written crossovers. Somehow, the absurdity of pastel ponies meeting Dr. Who or the X-Men or Elizabeth Bennett makes it totally plausible.

      MLP is also one of the only fandoms I've seen where you can make an OC who can seamlessly integrate with the story--because no matter who is the star in the show (the main six these days, various ponies in other generations), it's clear there is room for other ponies doing their own thing and living their own lives, perhaps in the background, the woods, or the next town over.

      ReplyDelete
    88. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 8:41 PM

      @Anonymous
      Hey, I'm just saying, we blow this show up more than it is.

      ReplyDelete
    89. What got me into these ponies? Well, I was a resident on /b/, pretty much there every free minute. I was miserable with it all though, in retrospect, I was probably more miserable than I actually realised.

      Then the pony threads started to appear, at first I just ignored it in favour of other threads, but they stuck around, and eventually I just had to take a peek.

      I saw a lot of rage over how much of a contrast ponies are to /b/, and a lot of love about how something as innocent as ponies can survive and thrive in the darkest hole of the internet. I lurked and laughed at all of this insanity, saving the OC as I went.

      I started to get more curious though as time went on. Reading through the comments of the fans, I came to realise that it wasn't a group of really strange /b/tards who liked this show, it was made of lots of different /b/tards. Surely something of such wide appeal is worth is looking at after all, right? So I got into a livestream and watched all 15 episodes at the time with the exception of Call of the Cutie (the streamer disliked that episode). By episode 3, I KNEW I was in love with the show.

      What made me stay with the ponies after all this time? Everything. The show is a truly wonderful thing, it's got beautiful music, gorgeous artwork, and storylines that are far more enjoyable than that of other kid's shows today. There is also the characters, the background characters, and the world the show's team has created.

      Oh, the universe that is before us. It is full of all of the elements for almost any kind of endeavor one's imagination wishes to go on. It is a very inviting universe, that begs to be explored. Because of that, I found myself writing my first few fan-fictions ever.

      Nowadays, I do not write so much, but I find myself bursting with creativity and willing to channel that creativity to things I am more skilled at: GTA SA mods in particular.

      I will probably attempt writing again, but only when I feel I am ready, which may be really soon.

      I suppose the answer to your question is this:
      We are all driven to create all works of art in the name of our favourite little equines because they brought us a wonderful, shining beacon of joy in a midst the mess that is the internet and society. Something that brings anyone pure joy and happiness is certain to earn appreciation, and in the case of the ponies, it goes beyond merely thanking the show's team and supporting them, but going out of our way to really express our love for the show with the best works of art and largest of efforts that has ever come out of any fandom to date.

      ReplyDelete
    90. @Anonymous

      Don't say that! Everypony is capable of creativity. Don't be afraid to fail every once in a while!

      ReplyDelete
    91. When you see other people being as enthusiastic as yourself about something slightly unorthodox, you want to push yourself to show them how much better than them that you can do, in hopes that they will in turn show you how much better than YOU that THEY can do. We push each other, motivate each other, harmonize and resonate with each others intentions, and most importantly, we all CARE about each other. Most fanbases would be exactly the same if they were one person short of what they were the previous day. But bronydom would not be the same if anypony among us weren't here.

      ReplyDelete
    92. it's funny, because seth also said that he'd never do any OC pony stuff when he started EqD, and look where he is now

      ReplyDelete
    93. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      With all due respect, I think every single comment on this post begs to differ.

      I can't say the show itself had the same effect on me as it did on many others. I was already an active writer on FFN, and I was already open to trying new things. What I got out of this show was a tremendous shift in how I viewed the world. Before I started watching My Little Pony, I would've looked at something I don't understand (people who like Twilight comes to mind) and simply mocked it without even thinking about it. I'm still trying to get out of that habit, but what this show has done for me is made me realize that there are often scenarios in life where I don't know as much about people and the things they like as I think I do.

      I'm no stranger to being judged based on enjoying things that a 17-year-old guy typically wouldn't; as I said before, I've spent the last two years writing fan fiction for The Lion King. I realized it somewhat back then, and I've realized it in full now that I'm a brony: what a person likes or doesn't like is never a valid reason to judge them. Four months ago, I couldn't for the life of me understand why any self-respecting male would be caught dead watching My Little Pony. Now, if I saw a dude wearing a Strawberry Shortcake shirt, I'd probably ask him what got him into that. In short, this show gave me a king-sized shot of perspective that I was sorely missing before.

      And that's what I find to be magic about it.

      ReplyDelete
    94. Personally, I have kind of a social awkwardness problem, even in anonymous message boards. Each time someone mentions an error or criticizes one of my posts (if I ever DO post something), I feel really, really bad. And if it's that bad with just posts, imagine how it would be with fanfiction, drawings or some other type of content.

      But for some reason in this fanbase alone I felt so hard the need to contribute with something, anything, that I found the courage to go ahead and do it. And I haven't felt the fear of negative opinions as much as I have before.

      I don't know what it is about these ponies, but I for one am thankful that they let me be able to express myself.

      ReplyDelete
    95. I think the reason is because of the potential for creativity. This show has given me multiple ideas; although I haven't really ever followed through with them, I think.

      ReplyDelete
    96. @Aquaman52
      > Now, if I saw a dude wearing a Strawberry Shortcake shirt, I'd probably ask him what got him into that.

      Great, now I'm wondering if Strawberry Shortcake could acquire the same degree of respectability as MLP... I'd honestly like to see that happen.

      ReplyDelete
    97. Black magic and witchcraft!

      Just kidding, really, I'm with the others here. I think it's just that MLP by its very nature is very friendly, and the community as a result is supportive of artists of various calibre.

      One thing I've found is that people are often more clever/talented than they think they are... And their confidence can be easily crushed by a passing troll.

      The MLP fandom is, while not perfect, a lot more supportive as a whole when it comes to other members of the community, allowing everypony to take their turn in the spotlight with less fear of backlash.

      Thing is, art isn't just about drawing a pretty picture or arranging words... it's also about ideas and inspiration... Even the most creative of souls can run out of ideas, and I've seen a great number of extremely talented artists being unproductive not because they don't have time, but because they lack the inspiration...

      And by allowing everypony to take their turn to shine, we practically open up an infinite well of inspiration for the more talented among us. Think back, how many times have you seen your favourite artist/writer comment that their inspiration for a particular piece came from a fellow brony?

      That is how I see it, at least

      ReplyDelete
    98. Hmmm....

      Well, I know i'm a woman/filly, and I am pretty much a magnet to cute things or anything a respectful yet craze anime fan would suggest. And hard to believe.... I treat MLP:FiM like any other "good" anime (about the same level as Puella Magi Madoka Magica).

      Obviously, i'm a person/pony who can draw, and I did quite a few fanart... Not the best enough for Drawfriend though. But ATM i'm also working on a actual fan-comic with the crossover of Umineko meets ponies in a "Panty-and-Stocking" (and MLP) style. (Note to Seth/Cereal: When this is finish, I may go send a e-mail to you about this comic thing. Can't quartette on the quality though. But it was well-written by an fanfic addict who digest MLP and Seacats for a short time!)

      So yea... I guess ponies gave me a new direction in "art style". Otherwise I will keep MLP:FiM as a very good example of how "girl shows" should be, because Lauren and staff deserves metals for those.

      ReplyDelete
    99. The last time I'd written a fanfic was around 2002 or so. That was for the "Chip 'n' Dale's Rescue Rangers" fansite "The Acorn Cafe" It was a 15-chapter epic titled "Once Upon A Dream", under my then pen-name "Loki". The reason then was the same as the reason now - this show features fully-realized, three dimensional characters that are interesting to write for. They have flaws that are fun to explore. They interact with one another on multiple levels. They live in a world that is populated with fantastic things, where tension and danger are easy to find. I'm not talking about crossovers or self-inserts and stuff here, I'm talking about the joy of creating an adventure in the framework that is already here... Okay, so I haven't written anything major yet, just an entry in the speedfic challenge because I was intrigued by that particular goal. The bug has bitten, however, and is still nibbling. When I do put something major up here - I want it to be good.

      ReplyDelete
    100. Ya know what else? I visited the Acorn Cafe recently - there is still love for the Rescue Rangers, but now the off-topic board is overrun with, you guessed it, PONIES! Amazing how much cross-pollination there is, you know?

      ReplyDelete
    101. Spurred by this post, I actually just did a blog post about how writing fanfics lately has helped me grow as a writer.

      http://coreywwilliams.wordpress.com/2011/07/07/pony-fanfiction-an-ongoing-saga/

      I do feel like that because of this fandom, I have learned about some of my strengths and weaknesses as a writer and become better because of it. As someone who wants to one day be a full-time writer, I can't thank everyone here enough.

      ReplyDelete
    102. There are many reasons for writing stuff on ponies. Your liking of the show or curiosity on how it would turn out are two good reasons. Though a strong reason may be all the potential behind these ponies. Here we have characters with very distinct personalities drawn in beautiful animation written by talented writers. The possibilities are endless. Anyone can do anything with these characters. How would this character do in that situation? What happens when these two are stuck together? What if my other favorite series met these ponies? Tons and tons of ideas spawn because these characters are so easy to understand and inspire others to use them in any form they wish from lighthearted fun to shipping fics to Cupcakes.

      ReplyDelete
    103. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      If this show weren't what it was, it wouldn't be what it is, but it is what it is; therefore, it is what it is. :)

      Look at this comments section, filled to the brim of fans who talk for paragraphs upon paragraphs of how the show touched them in a positive way. This is literally unlike any fanbase I have ever seen, and I've been on the internet for well over a decade. The presence of the show became a lightning rod for people who needed something like this, something to tell them that it's OK to have a little childlike joy in their lives, that it's OK to smile and laugh, that it's OK to be a man and still have emotions.

      This isn't directly due to the show, to be sure, but the show is nonetheless a facilitator of it all, and that alone almost makes it a self-fulfilling statement that the show is great: it's great because everyone thinks it's great and has created such positivity due to their thinking it's great. And that's something that I really think should not be discounted. The world needs more love and tolerance. What difference does it make if it's a show for little girls that induces such a thing?

      ReplyDelete
    104. People love the ponies, what can you say? <3 But seriously now. I think many things contribute to the love of our favorite "little marshmallow ponies".

      For one thing, they're just so loveable. They truly are. They have great character designs, nice and simplistic. They have depth too. They aren't just simple characters put there for the sake of having a character in place. They actually have a fair bit of depth to them. And in a show intended for children, that can be a little tough to really find. I'm sure most of us can agree with that. And the stories are no different. They actually have depth too and are genuinely fun to watch. They can be silly, but not so silly. And they can be serious, but not too serious. They all have a little life lesson and it doesn't over-do itself either. The stories really help bring us closer to the characters and make us love them even more. Dynamic, adorable (though I know some of the men here would be hesitant to admit that ;)), fun, and sometimes hilarious (See: Pinkie Pie), make both the characters and stories they're apart of something a lot of people can really enjoy and get behind. And many people can see themselves in at least one character, sometimes more. Of course that was intended. But that always helps bring them closer to the fans as well.

      Second, I think it just happens to be the type of show to attract the artistic types. Of varying mediums and degrees. Because its just so loveable and dynamic, it's bound to attract a lot of people of different backgrounds. And the artists are no different. But I do think the show does have a certain... aspect, to it that makes it especially appealing to the artistically-inclined. And I feel the same way. It's hard for me to truly pinpoint exactly all the reasons I love the show, but I really do love it. I think it's great and it's at the top of my chart for my favorite TV shows. You could compare it to Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends too. Since Lauren Faust was also a brainchild behind the creation of that show. It was also quite popular and I noticed it also had quite the number of artists who liked it. I never really got into it myself, but that was a little something I noticed about that show too. So I guess this show has that same dynamic and draw to it. Really, like I said above, I think it just has such loveable characters and that's why people seem so fond of the show.

      Third, we also have some very strong support from the team that creates the show. They really do listen to us and take our input to heart. It's rare to find the type of support that we have gotten from the Animators, Producers, Directors, everyone it seems behind the magic of MLPFiM. I believe that also weighs in heavily on why some people only love it even more. I think I'd also include myself in on that group as well. I find it very cool they listen so closely to us and really consider what we have to say. Even if we weren't their initial targeted audience. They have been so good to us and so cool about this sudden splurge of older fans to the show. I'm honored to have such a great team of awesome and talented people behind the show and I thank them profusely for all their hard work and time they put into it. So there is that too that contributes.

      As for what hooked me into the show. I think it's a combination of all I stated above. The great characters and stories. The awesome fan base that continually churns out simply amazing works of art. And the great team that tirelessly works on the show. It all combines to make simply one awesome time for all. And I really hope we have a lot more time ahead of us to enjoy this great show and the great people it brings together. :)

      ReplyDelete
    105. @The Dread Pirate Roberts
      You should jump back on the Cafe, Loki, I'm quite certain there's a number of people who'd enjoy seeing you again. ;)

      ReplyDelete
    106. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 9:10 PM

      @GabuEx
      Seriously, please stop pretending that the show is more than what it is. Given the chance ANYTHING could have made these people creative, the show just so happened to have been there.

      ReplyDelete
    107. I think it's very obvious that the reason we're inspired to do things in the name of ponies because it was started on 4chan, meaning it gets plenty of attention quickly, and every single episode is easily accessible on Youtube.

      I wish companies weren't so butthurt about copyrights for shows. If a show is impossible to watch on regular TV anyway, what's the point of banning it on Youtube? When a show is really good, it DESERVES to get attention. This extremely large pony fandom is a perfect example of that.

      It's also a show that takes an idea that was......literally absolutely nothing besides ponies grazing and being girly, and turned it into a series of situations that can be related to real life.

      It's a beautiful thing, and I think we have Hasbro to thank. If they gave a crap about ponies being uploaded in full HD quality on Youtube, Pony fandom would not spread NEARLY as fast as it has/is/does

      ReplyDelete
    108. For anybody that's still reading after 100 some comments just lemme add my two cents.

      I never had a way that I felt comfortable expressing myself in so alot of my emotions were pushed down. Ponies just sorta beckon you and say "Hey. Confide in me bro"

      ReplyDelete
    109. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      If ANYTHING could have made them creative, then why this show? Why not any of the other hundreds upon hundreds of shows out there? Why is the fanbase for this show so welcoming and inclusive? No other show has a fanbase like this one does, and the only way to explain that is that it's because of the show. Otherwise, it WOULD be the case that anything could have made all these people creative - which it isn't.

      What is so wrong with thinking that this fanbase - and by extension, the show that facilitated it - is something special? When I look out at all of these people who are happy, joyful, and full of warmth, and who feel part of something meaningful, why do you want to tell them not to be this way? It makes no sense. This is exactly what the world needs more of.

      ReplyDelete
    110. @Horizon Bound

      Eh, I prefer to give people the benefit of the doubt and assume they aren't trolling, and at any rate, I've said about all that can be said on the subject. I just want everyone to feel the love. :(

      ReplyDelete
    111. Hmm... what causes all of this? I think it's one of those very strange things that becomes ginormous simply because it's there.

      I describe getting into this fandom because of its reputation as watching someone jump off of cliff. At first, you laugh at the absurdity of it, and wait nearby to point and laugh at the inevitable mess that person will become. However, after a while and you haven't heard a loud *thud* yet, you begin to be curious about, at the very least, exactly how big that cliff is, and eventually end up peering over it, only to find that the pit is actually shallow and filled with all sorts of wondrous delights, which makes you want to jump in too, and someone was watches you as you do it and so on and so fourth until you have piles upon piles of people in this very spacious pit of goodness and-

      ...I think I lost my metaphor. Anyways, the creativity comes once you've actually fallen into the fandom. Adoring something so ridiculous on the outside provides a sort of safety in obscurity; once you've shrugged off what people will think of you for liking something to such a great degree, it's an incredibly liberating thing. That complete lack of shame can foster some of the best creativity the world has ever seen.

      I don't see this ever being replicated by any other fandom; what other universe has such a large following, yet has such an unappealing first impression that the majority of the fans are dedicated? ...Star Trek, maybe, but considering that that series was what INVENTED fan fiction...

      ...yeah, I guess it makes a lot of sense when you think about it... we are the new trekkies. And considering the stuff THAT fandom pumped out (eg. automatic doors, cell phones), I think that this fandom has a very, VERY bright future ahead of it...

      ReplyDelete
    112. I've wrote fanfiction from other universes before, mainly Pokemon. Mainly on /vp/. A day after its birth I wrote the Apocalypse: New World story that turned into a thread where everyone was writing the story, and it was amazing. Some shippy stuff and some sad stuff in the writefag threads (was I supposed to type writefriend?), and for a while I was the culprit of the grimdark fic threads that would of made Cupcakes look like a happy ending.

      And recently I've been extremely tempted to try my hand at drawing & writing ponies. Why? I have no clue. Reading stories like Spark, Nocturne, Fallout Equestria and The Ballad of Twilight Sparkle might have something to do with it. I think most of the current authors would of called somebody insane if they told them they'd be writing My Little Pony fanfiction last year. Besides it being MLP, many known authors didn't even write at all before they got hooked on the series.

      I mean, I'm sitting here on Windows 8, playing Pokemon Black. I'm loading Applebuck Season on youtube while I pack a bowl & thinking of a Trixairity fic that's been bubbling in my mind.
      This show has also made me want to draw with a fire that I've never had before beside with Halo 2. Draw.
      Me? Draw? I can draw like a 2nd grader. Stick people. ...No, actually, because my lil cousin just passed Kindergarten and she can draw Fluttershy nice. So I draw like a three year old. Yet here I am, ready to sketch once everyone goes to sleep at my house.

      I couldn't really say what it is about this show. About the Universe of Pony. But it's certainly magical.
      Must be all the friendship, I guess.

      ReplyDelete
    113. I dunno really. I just like ponies.

      ReplyDelete
    114. It's an interesting question, to be sure. Although I have written plenty, I had actually never in my life written a word of fanfic before MLP.

      What about it spurred (heh) my creativity?

      I would answer the question with the following points, many of which are mirrored above:

      * Realistic, 3-dimensional characters.

      * A rich, internally-consistent setting.

      * A clear and recognizable tone and style.

      * And perhaps most importantly: It made me smile.
      Actually, truly, genuinely smile, in a way that
      very few works of fiction ever have.

      ReplyDelete
    115. @krypqe You make it sound like we're all addicted. In which case, I have no idea what you're talking about.

      *breathes in from pony supplement inhaler*

      ReplyDelete
    116. Every so often, a universe comes along with such compelling characters, and so much room for the imaginations of those exposed to it, that those creative enough cannot help but fill it up with their ideas. Star Wars is a prime example, as is Harry Potter.

      And this is a recursive process; for each idea brought into the universe that is compelling enough, more can arise. In this sense, fandoms are like resonant chambers of creativity. Although the initial impulse is not necessarily loud or sonorous, the end result is more than its initiator.

      But My Little Pony does something Star Wars and Harry Potter did not. George Lucas has said in no uncertain terms that only the two trilogies are canon. J.K. Rowling's lawyers regularly dole out cease and desist orders for errant fanfiction. Hasbro parodies raunchy club music and R-rated shock comedies to promote the show, mirroring the creative endeavors of the show's fans. They incorporate fan terms, names and humor into the show in unobtrusive but noticeable ways. In a sense, the ideas that the fans have added to the world are being processed through the original creators' lens, and fed back to the community it came from. Where Star Wars and Harry Potter were simple echo chambers, My Little Pony is a feedback loop, and it keeps getting louder.

      The internet helps. Back in the eighties and nineties, the Star Wars fanon developed slowly because books were the most common medium for it to propagate through. There were interest groups doing Star Wars on the web, but they were larval, at best. The Harry Potter bug had the internet, even if it was slower back then, but being stifled by the series' creator ultimately cased the bug to fade out.

      With My Little Pony, the rate at which the creative reverberations bounce around in the feedback loop is faster than ever, making the effect even more striking.

      ReplyDelete
    117. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 9:41 PM

      @GabuEx
      That's just pretenciousness talking. That's what I don't like about a lot of bronies, they act like this show is bigger than it is. It's a show for little girls that lots of guys happen to like, get over yourself.

      ReplyDelete
    118. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony So... you're basically saying that a show - which spawned numerous podcasts, turned into a huge internet subculture, and created websites (including Equestria Daily which, let me rephrase, garners 200,000 views a day) - makes people pretentious by thinking there's something special about it?

      Correct me if I'm wrong, I've been to big... biig fandoms in the past, man, and this community is NOTHING like I've never seen before. This show is more than what it is - not because of the show itself, but by how people reacted to the show and how it turned into something big in a matter of months.

      And besides, this show does have something special in it for me at least. If you came across my usual self before MLP, and you posted this here comment, I wouldn't have given you this straightforward reply. I would've shamelessly called you names, humiliated your intelligence, annoyed you for days by posting something nonsensical and demeaning, or some other unfair and moronic thing like that. Would you then say that MLP is just like any other show? I've definitely watched other series, and it never changed me this drastically.

      We're all simply baffled about how MLP impacted and motivated us. Suddenly this huge change happened, and we're still clueless as to why it happened or how it happened - suddenly you wake up and you're a brony and you're asking yourself 'why? why is this show so good? why am I writing fanfiction when I've never written it before?'

      Please look into solid facts before ya judge other people based on your own experiences with the show? It might not have changed yours, but (due to the facts I have just laid out) it is safe to say it changed ours.

      Cheers~

      ReplyDelete
    119. I've given up trying to figure out exactly what it is about Friendship is Magic that has me hooked. All I know is it puts a huge, dumb grin on my face and make me feel more positive and very little has done that for me in a lot of years. They aren't a cure, yet, but they're the best therapy I've ever come across for my depression.

      And now I'm drawing ponies almost daily. Which is saying something considering my depression induced art block lasts almost years at a time. And drawing ponies has got me drawing more of my own stuff and commissions again.

      Just so crazy that a My Little Pony show is having such a positive impact on my life.

      ReplyDelete
    120. It's another one of those things that make FiM magic instead of just a great show.

      I do plenty of writing otherwise but haven't gotten into fanfics.

      However, I didn't do much drawing and when i did it annoyed the hell out of me. Because of my machinima hobbies and personal perfectionism, I've drawn alot of storyboards, and spent most of that time going "Y CANT I DRAW SHOTS" However, seeing not only the show but all the wonderful places artists have taken it (namely, the ATG - thanks again alumni and Phoe) inspired me to give it a shot. My first few were okay, but they got alot better and i quickly realized its something i should have done a long time ago.

      This is the real reason i love being a brony. The show is awesome, but its all these secondary effects that make the community awesome too. Bronyism is an inspiring movement that makes the world seem a bit brighter. Every day i see all range of positive impacts on people, from rediscovering artistic talent to improving self esteem, ect. It's really magic, i think

      ReplyDelete
    121. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 9:51 PM

      @sandman
      My point is, we're taking this into a silly new level. We're turning a hobby, into an obsession. Bronies on Youtube, and Bronies on non MLP communities aren't like this, it's only on the Brony communities where people take act like the show is life changing. You realize your not special, there are people in every other fandom who can claim the same thing you said. And another thing, I don't understand why people act like it's life changing? The show was made for little girls, and yet we're acting like it's the next great philosophical movement.

      ReplyDelete
    122. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony Okay, let me ask you somethin.

      If you by any chance wake up in the middle of the street naked with a hella hangover, would you question how you got there?

      Let me rephrase:

      If you by any chance realize that you were writing fanfiction/drawing fanart/buying mlp toys/or just watching a show that was meant for little girls, would you question how you got there?

      yeah, we're all just wonderin the same thing here.

      ReplyDelete
    123. SCIENCE!!! Quality writing begets emotional attachment, and emotional attachment is responsible for just about everything we have ever achieved.

      ReplyDelete
    124. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 9:54 PM

      @Anonymous
      Maybe it's because you like the show and had nothing else to do on a Friday night?

      ReplyDelete
    125. OK, let me just start out by saying that there is a high chance that I am located on the Autism spectrum, and this being said that when all sheer cuteness, excellent voice acting, and enthralling story line come together I get this feeling I've never had before. I believe it is love.

      ReplyDelete
    126. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      Hey, Dave, glad you replied!

      The thing is, like I've mentioned - it is life changing.

      If it wasn't for you, at least it was for me.

      It might just be a show for little girls - a cartoon no less - but I have learned something about it.

      I learned that people can deal with debates like these maturely. And I've learned to become a better person.

      I owe the straightening of my morals to this show. I've dealt with my problems using what I've learned. I've become a better person by practicing these morals.

      This show isn't just a show, Dave. It's a show where you can learn, or relearn something from it. I learned that there's more to life than being a pessimistic bastard.

      Is this not proof enough that something simple like this could change someone's life?

      Besides... how can you say what can change anyone's life and what can't? A simple, caring word from a friend or family can veer you out of being an alcoholic.

      It's just different for other people. We're all just pondering the whys of this fandom, that's all. What's so bad about that? If you don't like the ponderings, what's the harm in letting it happen?

      Cheers~

      ReplyDelete
    127. I could rant about how I planned to write a book and how my username is spelled wrong and all sorts of terribly boring things, but I think that a summary would be better:

      I think through things in a way that would be great for a story. Sadly, I cant write worth beans. I cant draw worth beans either, but my brain works better on imagining an image along with a story than it does a story alone. Thus, after being partialy inspired by the absolutely MIND BLOWINGLY AMAZING ART done by this fandom, I thought to myself: "Why dont I take some art classes, or at least do SOMETHING to start in art, since my dream job is working as a game designer anyway, and to do that you need to know how to do EVERYTHING." Promptly after that I suggested to my parents that it might be a good idea to, over the course of the next few years, try to learn something of art. My dad had the response of "I have a tablet I dont use." Divine intervention? mayhap. Either way it means thatI might be able to... dangit. thats what I hate about writing on the internet; at this point my brain tells me to erase everything I have written and leave to advoide possable anxiety. Too bad.

      It MEANS that I might be able to get a head start on both art-stuff (although probably not anything NEAR the quality of the Drawfriend art) and my dream job, and I owe it to marshmallow ponies. I would say wat, but im too busy screaming "**** YES!" to the winds.

      ReplyDelete
    128. Cereal, your story sounds almost identical to mine (except I found out about the show in December, take that!). I've always been told I was a good writer, but I struggled to come up with something to write about. This is obviously a huge problem for me artistically, since you never improve if you don't write. I always thought only losers wrote or read fanfiction, so it took me a while to overcome that preconception. After I wrote Cargo Cult, it was like a tap was turned on in my brain.

      I have no idea what it is about these freakin' ponies, but they just inspire a flood of stories in me and it's helped me build my confidence as a writer tremendously. I feel like I could actually write that novel I've always dreamed about now, and all because of a show about cartoon horses. Unbelievable. But awesome.

      ReplyDelete
    129. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony Actually I hated this until my friend forced me to watch it.

      .... weeks later, I was wondering what the hell happened.

      I'm not like you, you're not like me. Why're you thinking that everyone else have exactly the same experiences as you? : /

      Oh well, everyone else replied to you and I'm guessing you won't change your mind or consider this all fairly anyway, so it's pointless to go on this shtick. I'm outta here-

      ReplyDelete
    130. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 10:05 PM

      @sandman
      CONGRATULATIONS! You have successfully turned a girls show into a philosophy! Alright, I am terrified now. Terrified of what we're going to become. We're actually acting like this show will make the world a better place. This is why lots of people hate us, we're blind to our own concept, we're grown men who like My Little Pony. Why can't we learn to accept it? Why do we have to keep trying to justify it by saying "it's morals made me a better person!" even though it's bullcrap. We should all just say "There's something weird about me!" and leave it at that.

      ReplyDelete
    131. TL;DR Well, I watch it because I like the show.

      I started writing for it because I wanted to contribute to the story. I'm writing it the way I am because I wanted to tell a story that few had tried to tell. Perhaps there's a good reason for that, but I felt I had to at least try.

      I think the show is very cute. I think that the characters are all well defined. With a little more characterization, they could all shine heads and tails above characters in other series' I've followed over the years.

      I think I watch it because its a show that encourages love and friendship. Even great old cartoons like Rocky and Bullwinkle had their Boris Badenov's and Fearless Leader's. By adding antagonists in the next season, I think they're taking a risk. I'm still going to watch it though, because I want to give a new direction for the show a chance to succeed.

      I'll keep watching it until the end. I'll keep reading fanfiction until the end. I might even keep writing fanfiction myself until the end, but I'd have to get better to do that. In essence, I suppose I'm saying I love the show and I watch it because I love the show.

      ReplyDelete
    132. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      What I just told you is fact, Dave. It's pure fact, and even if you think it's going too far - it still happened, no matter what anyone says. Fact is something you can't say doesn't exist. I've already laid the facts out for you, and it's your choice to open your mind up. There's nothing else for me to say but our differing personalities - you with being laid back, and me being curious about this subculture.

      It might not have turned the world into a better place, but it turned me, and other fellow trolls I know, into a better person.

      But if you still don't believe me, then it's fine. I shrug my shoulders and all. Anon up there is right, at this point there is no use or chance in trying to change your mind... nor is there a point in trying to change ours or how this fandom perceives the show as something special.

      See ya, man!

      ReplyDelete
    133. I have characters that people like. Really like! I've written many stories before, but was always frustrated with the fact that I needed lots of character buildup. But, then, I stumble onto ponies. And onto a fandom that says the mentor of the main character is a tyrant.
      Bam, the idea hit me. Yes, she is a tryant... and she knows it. And she hates it. From there, things were easy
      Then, bang. People liked it. So I decided to expand the idea (and spam "it got worse.")

      ReplyDelete
    134. I don't think I would be anywhere near as enthralled with the show and its universe had it not been for all the crazily talented writers, video-makers, composers, and of course artists that exist in this fandom. I remember commenting on a thread way back in the infancy of me discovering MLP, asking how far I thought I'd go into the fandom. I set five limits:

      1. Never draw ponies (I never draw anything, so I didn't think that would be too hard. Yet 2 months later, here I stand as a Brony Artist Training ground alumnus)
      2. Never read a shipping fic (Broke that rule quite a ways back)
      3. Never tell anyone irl about this (I think the next day I broke that)
      4. NEVER download pony music (yeah, in retrospect I knew I was never going to hold steady in that)
      5. For the love of all that is Pinky, don't read Cupcakes! (I still haven't, thankfully)

      And I only stayed strong in that last rule because of my love of the show (and me not wanting to ruin a character).

      Anyway, addressing the actual question, it just feels like the second one brony contributes to the fandom, the next is inspired by it, and feels the urge to give something back as well. And every time a fantastic work is presented for all to enjoy, the effect only keeps building until it overwhelms that person, inspiring them to make something they can call their own, something they can share with the rest of us as we have been with them.

      We give each other gifts in the form of expressing our talents, and when we receive a gift, we feel the urge to give back. Few communities have been so deeply pervaded with this mutual enjoyment, something I think is innate in the fandom due to the nature of the show itself.

      ReplyDelete
    135. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      Maybe if you, I don`t know, provided REASOSNS for saying "that's just pretentiosness" to every post, your arguments would make more sense to everyone else?

      Because your posts are basically boiling down to "nuh-uh" without any explanations towards your own POV.

      ReplyDelete
    136. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony Many have accepted the fact that they are well grown adults watching a show for kids I don't see where your getting people denying the obvious

      ReplyDelete
    137. Personal rant thread? YES! Personal rant thread!

      I've always felt like kind of an odd duck when it came to doing things. When I was a little kid, people always told me that almost everything I did was amazing (They for the most part meant it too, I was a pretty smart kid). I blame this for my current state of inertia. A while ago I got tired of being the technically oriented little assburgers kid and, after taking a jewelry/metalwork class in high school, actually got interested in art.

      Whenever I'd try to draw something, or write something, I'd inevitably always get frustrated as nothing came out the way I wanted, eventually scrapping the whole thing. I was also afraid of people seeing me fail, so I never practiced except when I was at home, with no-one else in the house. Which never happened.

      Ponies though... I don't know. Maybe it's just that I'm stuck in Mexico for a month and have nothing to do but fly and fix a fleet of remote control helicopters (No, I'm not bitter, dad, I'd love to hear more about your cyclic control adjustments, honest, I swear), but I've always been sort of removed from the world, building little universes in my head. I always told myself that I would put some of those ideas down on paper, but as before mentioned, nothing I ever did matched my unrealistic expectations. Once I got exposed to ponies and the brony community though, well, just seeing how happy the show is, and how overwhelmingly positive everypony here is (An internet community with manners? c'est pas possible!) is actually really encouraging. I've finally decided to start writing, that being my strong suite (drawing will come later, or so I tell myself) so that I can actually share one of the little worlds inside my head.

      I'm currently writing a story inspired by two of Moes pictures, about a Spanish Pike-and-Shot formation that lands in the middle of a battered, war-torn Equestria. I'm getting anxious wondering what everypony will think of it, since I have a tendency to jump headfirst into situations without having the skills to handle them properly, but if this is the only way to improve... well, if Fluttershy can stare down a dragon, I can do this.

      ReplyDelete
    138. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 10:20 PM

      @MaskOfData
      What's wrong with being a troll? Trolls don't hurt people. And being a Troll is funny as hell. Why would you give up something harmless that you liked, just because a bunch of ponies told you not to?

      ReplyDelete
    139. What inspires me to create art in the name of colourful marshmallowy ponies is simply my love for the craft! I was an artist LONG before MLP and will be long after it. I fell in love with the show and its pastel protagonists and, as I have with other things I've loved, I wanted to draw fan art for it!

      I shied away from it at first for the same reason's as most. I was afraid to admit I was a brony. But I finally came to terms with it, and was determined to contribute to the community!

      I lurked around the internet looking for art to reference. I scoured the sites, 4-chan (ponychan wasn't up yet), The Hub's official site, ponibooru and even Know Your Meme. I compiled a large folder full of pony art and vectors for reference, all that was left was to find an excuse to actually DO the drawing.

      It was thanks to Equestria Daily's Artist Training Grounds that I started to seriously draw ponies. Before that I'd doodle a head here or there. After 30 days of straight pony drawing I decided, I didn't want to stop.

      Now, I don't JUST draw ponies. I draw other things non-pony related all the time. But I noticed that because I was drawing every day my art (not just pony related) was getting MUCH better! My character's were more expressive, they seemed to have more life in them! As an artist who was always looking down on his work, it made me VERY happy!

      Anyways, I continue to draw daily (not always ponies) and I'm actually currently working on a mini-comic series that's about a set of OC ponies. I hope to finish it before Season 2 starts, or maybe just before next year.

      So, to all you other content creators out there, whatever your reason you're inspired to draw, write, compose, whatever; just keep on creating!

      ReplyDelete
    140. I think it's because the show itself is such a delight to the eye and heart that it makes its viewers want to be part of it. They want to be part of that world, and help build that world. I don't do fiction or art based on MLP:FiM, but I totally understand people who do. As long as they respect the source, I say more power to them.

      ReplyDelete
    141. @Anonymous

      Given his recent celebration of being a troll, I think it seems rather evident now why he isn't providing any reasons for what he's saying. :P

      ReplyDelete
    142. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony According to experience, it would be funny as hell if you were the troll. If you were the victim, however..?

      ... besides, do you even know what you're saying? Prove to us that trolling is funny as hell for the victim. Give us examples, too. Support your claims! Or how about you try and be trolled and get back to us on that?

      ReplyDelete
    143. To me. I'ts the world. A world full of charicters to explore(for writers like me) and background charicters with intresting enough desgins to create personalites. Not only that but the mane cast themselves are well rounded and thus inspire plenty of art and ideas. The world of equestria is so vibrant yet vauge that it just opens up a creativity vein, even if I havne't done much with it.

      ReplyDelete
    144. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 10:28 PM

      @Anonymous
      I've been trolled a lot of times, and I never felt bad, because I always remember that they're a bunch of guys behind computers. If you take Trolls serious, your doing something wrong.

      ReplyDelete
    145. @GabuEx There's just no point in trying to reply to him further. He should know that, as we all are aware, trolling bronies do not work as hilariously compared to Youtube.

      I'll just tap dance away while eating my toast.

      ReplyDelete
    146. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 10:34 PM

      By the way, I wasn't being a troll right now, just to let you know.

      ReplyDelete
    147. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony Unfortunately, I am not Dave. Nor is anyone in here for that matter.

      And no, before you ask, this world is not Dave World where everybody else is just like you.

      sandman? give me your toast.

      ReplyDelete
    148. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 10:37 PM

      @Anonymous
      I know that, however, I feel I will have done my job if I convince at least one person about how ridiculous he's acting.

      ReplyDelete
    149. @Anonymous It is not yours to take, heathen! AWAY WITH YOU AND YOUR TOAST-STEALING!

      ReplyDelete
    150. Gentlemen, I do believe we have a Gilda among us. Dave Mustang is not a brony, he is a hater sent to sow discord among the group.

      It is best to ignore whatever he says from now on. He is only trying to spread negativity and doubt. Nothing more. I'm not sure why else he would be here, saying the stuff he says.

      He shouldn't be shunned, but his words should carry no weight because they are hollow and filled with malice. If 99% of the comments didn't directly contradict what he was saying, he might have a point. But as one can clearly see via the comments section, this is not the case. Also, cynical brony sounds like an oxymoron to me.

      But hey, Dave, please continue to call us pretentious (and spell it wrong in the process) and claim this show is not special. You're really only making yourself look bad.

      Take care and good night, griffin.

      ReplyDelete
    151. @sandman My good sir, it seems our friend is still not providing evidence. Oh well! :DD

      I shall toast my own toast then - mostly to stop us from spamming (though you're seriously making me hungry). To the kitchens!

      ReplyDelete
    152. The thing that really hooked me for ponies was the community behind it all. I mean yeah I liked the show and I deiced I was going to watch the whole thing before I found the community but when I did find it it just brought these cute little ponies to a whole new level. I invent some small little things in my spare time like experimental rail guns, tasers, wind powered generators and batteries from dirt but I never really ever drew or anything like that yet I was going to college for graphic design and 2D and 3D animation. Then I saw these ponies and I was astounded by all of the fan art they had behind them, the fact that they where made in flash, and just about everything else I found out about them. this simple flash cartoon show motivated me to really get myself in gear with my degree so I deiced to make art for the community, I have done some vector work but mainly sketches right now. What I have become known for is my Vinyl Scratch guitar and my RD shoes and these are probably my most treasured pieces of art to this day. Another thing that really got me hooked on this was how nice the community is, I have never seen or been apart of a community this nice before, I mean that MadMax thing we did on the training grounds almost made me cry. I mean look at us, we didn't know MadMax personally (most of us) but we all love her artwork so we banded together and made some 140 images with MadMax in them because we heard she was going through a rough patch in life. What community out there does that? Pulls people together to help just one artist that some of us might not know but most do, most communities out there would just do nothing or laugh at them, we truly are an amazing bunch of people (and ponies).

      ReplyDelete
    153. All on my part, Seth: Make a marshmallow sculpture contest.

      ReplyDelete
    154. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 10:45 PM

      @Jeremy
      You just proved my point. You dismiss me as being a brony because I showed some objection to the unwritten rules of Bronydom. Also, I can't be cynical and a brony? And saying I didn't spell something right, way to be not pretentious.

      ReplyDelete
    155. I got into it because it was such a strange, tight knit sort of "club" of people from all over the place. They looked out for each other and yet where EVERYWHERE online. You can't find a forum today that lacks a pony thread.

      Once I was one of the bronies it just got even better. Never seen so much OC before, sometimes when I stand back and look at what this all revolves around its just insane and baffles the mind. Don't get me wrong, I love the show, but I'm really here for the community.

      ReplyDelete
    156. There is so much hate and antagonism on television. I'm officially tired of it. Last year, I found myself almost unable to watch TV. Family Guy had grown tiresome, recycled, and too dependent upon political satire and stoner slapstick to convey any charm. The Simpsons was going another year with scripts comprised entirely of 95% inside jokes. The Boondocks was doomed to stop at season 3, Metalocalpyse and Superjail left bad tastes in my mouth, Chowder got cancelled, Flapjack cancelled, and syndicated television was so awful I found myself growing to LIKE Two and a Half Men.

      I'll say it again. I started to LIKE Two and a Half Men.

      The playbook of almost every television plot was rooted in exploring and exposing the negative qualities of just about anything. Writing in television was pivotal to a negative connotation. Nothing encouraging, just showing how stupid their characters are, how willingly they let their lives slip away, how badly they ruin their own world, and how biblical their downfall emanates. Reality TV has racing full throttle to see who could hire the most shallow arrogant cast imaginable, whether it be brides deemed perfect by their husbands to be vehemently pressured into getting excessive quantities of plastic surgery, or indignant east coast stereotypes offensive enough to make even the generally good sports of Italy take umbrage. The very essence of entertainment had devolved into a bastard mix of ventriloquism and sadism, where there's no redemption, moral, or lesson to be had from it, just an unending chicane of masochistic pleasures, like we were just one Fall Sweeps away from abandoning the metaphor of it all with 'Human Plinko.'

      [continues below]

      ReplyDelete
    157. I was ready for a change. The more dramatic the change...the better.

      'Friendship is Magic' won me over by having great clever writing without having to resort to cheap sarcastic, cynical, or vulgar humor. By being restrained to the young girls target demographic, the show's creators had to bring their greatest creative juices and their A game to the table. They had to overcome the stigmas and prejudices being mounted against it, the phalanx of doubt, the insistence that legends like Lauren Faust were being enslaved or selling out to some evil corporate empire, and prove against all odds and previous failures that a girl's show CAN garner a devout following.

      And by Odin's chest hairs, did they succeed.

      That is what fascinates me the most. For the first time in my life, I'm watching a program that I will readily admit is made for little girls, not try to distort that feeling to justify some abstract sense of manliness on my own behalf, and state with absolute confidence that I am left astounded by how amazing it is. It is what you expect it to be, there's no denying it, and yet it makes you realize that despite the 'girly show' legacy haunting animation history, Friendship is Magic slays that ghost with supernova gusto.

      It annihilates it.

      Not a trace remains. People who have seen Friendship is Magic laugh when they hear 'girls shows don't get ratings.' We laugh at that! How we laugh! But was it not true that just nine months ago, we all would've agreed with that sentiment? That lingering spirit possessed all of us, and it took a genius visionary like Lauren Faust to exorcise it from all of us.

      ReplyDelete
    158. Thus, here we are, united under the label of bronies, but so widely diverse in what brought us all here. We all have our reasons, we all have our history, and we all find ourselves explaining to friends and family why we even like something that seems so unorthodox. We say it's the animation. We say it's the story. And sometimes we just take a page from the show itself and quote Pinkie Pie: just because we can't really explain it, doesn't mean it's not true. You just have to take that leap of faith.

      I took my leap in March. Much later than the average brony. I knew of the show for months, but avoided it just thinking that it wouldn't be my thing. Why would a fan of Archer, a fan of Justified, a fan of death metal ever be caught dead watching ponies? But I grew tired of those things, and had to be honest with myself. I had to admit that there was a curiosity dormant in my psyche that needed to be satisfied. I needed to see for myself that the spirit of failure beset upon girl-centric animation departed.

      I took that leap of faith. And I believed.

      The notion of 'watching shows for little girls is totally lame' is now no more. We have one exception to that assertion. Yes, just one. Maybe a handful of others that have slipped through the cracks of history. But one is all it takes. And that one is kicking the door, no, DYNAMITING the door wide open for similar shows to be made, and instilling that distinct feeling of hope among those television executives, the suits who foot the bill, that girls' television is no longer the 'high risk venture' it used to be.

      Guilty pleasure? Sincere endeavor? To me, it's the Cinderella story of the year. It was faced with great adversity every day up until it aired, but it proved the doubters, the haters, the NEIGH-H-H-sayers all...it proved them wrong.

      Cereal, Seth, you do a great job. We are not obliged to explain why we like the show so much, and in all honesty, we're so numerous and fast-growing there's almost no need to. But after reading your stories, and the stories of others here of their own discovery, it just adds one more dimension to the brony following that shows how dynamic we all are; that despite our differences, our geography, our ages, our sexes, we learn that simply being open to the tenets of 'love and tolerance' is being open to every single person in the world who does the same.

      ReplyDelete
    159. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      I can't speak for everyone here, so I'm just gonna say my piece.

      If you want to talk cynicism, ok then. I know cynicism. All I have to do is open my front door or turn on the tv or talk to another person and I'll get a healthy dose of it. And I too have become cynical as hell over the years, whether I wanted to or not. I've been conditioned. Sometimes I catch myself looking at every possible negative bit of anything, no matter how seemingly good. And I've grown to hate that, quite frankly. I've become apathetic as hell these past few years.

      This show is one of the last few damn things in my life I can look at without cynicism. I can just watch it and take it for what it is, and it makes me happy. This show, and this fandom, have made me more happy than I can tell you.

      So I ask you: Can I have this ONE thing? Please? We're all well aware of what we're watching and what we're doing. But it's quite obvious we're here because it's making a lot of us happy. Yes, I love the show for it's animation and writing and humor, etc. But the fandom associated with it just helps breathe even more life into it, and make it into something even bigger. I'm not claiming it's a "philosophy" but it IS something that's become a substantial part of my life recently, and for the better.

      The (mostly) loving, open-minded members of this community have made me feel...how can I describe it...safe? Optimistic? I dunno. It's just, the show and the community is like this warm place in my heart and despite how sappy that sounds that's no bullshit.

      I'm not trying to get into a huge debate or anything with you, I understand that obviously you don't feel the same way as the rest of us. But I'm trying to get you to maybe see it from our point of view, if only just a little.

      ReplyDelete
    160. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      Dave, a man named Henry Rollins wants to have a word with you.

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1SuMgOnaXk

      ReplyDelete
    161. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      But that's just it. You're not doing it for any other reason than to get a rise out of us. And you're the first "brony" I've ever heard of that was basically antagonistic without prompt. Every brony I've encountered has been positive, at least within the community, because the show engenders positive feelings. And the pointing out the misspelling was really just to knock you off your high horse. Sure, you may be cynical, but save it for the real world. It's way more deserving of it than here. Nobody is going to agree with you here, unless you make some sock puppets or something. And btw, if someone does happen to agree with you, I'll highly suspect it's a sock puppet unless Seth or Cereal themselves tell me otherwise. Because you are fighting a losing battle, my friend. Your time would be better spent elsewhere. But, you know, whatever you wanna do is fine.

      ReplyDelete
    162. I think what moves us to write about them is the same thing that moves anybody to write about any setting they love: we love experiencing stories about these characters, and we're saddened that there aren't more to read about them—or, indeed, that the kind of stories we want to read about them might never be animated, given the constraints Hasbro insists upon for the series.

      And so we reach the same conclusion fans of so many other settings do when they've reached the end of their setting: if there isn't any more "official" stuff to consume, we will write our own.

      I don't think there's any one particular ingredient we can point to as being the catalyst. The whole is more than the sum of its parts. And we love the whole, we want more…and so we make more.

      I would not at all be surprised to find this was the rationale behind every single fanfic as far back as when the ancient Greek storytellers invented their own myths about what Zeus and company had done lately.

      ReplyDelete
    163. Dave Mustang (AKA the clophater)July 7, 2011 at 10:58 PM

      @private-enemy
      This isn't pretentious, this is you just saying why you like the show and the community.

      ReplyDelete
    164. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      You still haven`t explained your rationale behind the whole "pretentious" comment you keep repeating, while everyone else has explained theirs.

      ReplyDelete
    165. @Dave Mustang (AKA the clophater) You're contradicting yourself how is his reply ANY different than Sandmans

      ReplyDelete
    166. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:00 PM

      @PaxImbrium
      I like Henry Rollins, but I don't agree with everything he says.

      And I'm not Cynical in the real world, not even on most web communities, I actually save it for places like this.

      ReplyDelete
    167. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony So why save it for here exactly I'm curious.

      ReplyDelete
    168. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:04 PM

      @Anonymous
      Because I don't like the thinking of about 97% of the people here.

      ReplyDelete
    169. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      At least you're admitting that you're only here to troll. That's cool I guess. Well, have fun anyway.

      ReplyDelete
    170. Guys guys guys - it's useless to give Dave more attention. His arguments are truly unsupported (I'm sorry, Dave, but it... actually is). He's already given his own opinion, we've already given ours, and he's not even fighting with a bite anymore.

      Even if he's not a troll, he should know that his complaints and name-calling here will not work. On the other hand our efforts are just going no where, that I could say.

      .... and being an ex-troll, I'm... quite sure that he is truly not aware of the inner-workings of one.

      Besides, what everyone else wrote above is inspiring and positive as it is! Good luck to Madmax, btw, I just found out about it through James, and I hope she's doing well :)

      ReplyDelete
    171. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:07 PM

      @Jeremy
      I'm not trolling, I'm expressing myself.

      ReplyDelete
    172. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony So why do you do this to yourself? I kinda see what you mean when your talking about this "turning into a philosophical." However why does it bother you so much that people say this show helped them change things about themselves?

      ReplyDelete
    173. Part of it is, I think, a backlash.

      Cynicism is the rotten heart of today's Internet. Deconstructing any good news. praising destruction more than creation, valuing "'tude'" over sincerity... this is what the bulk of Internet "creativity" has been. And it's reached even into children's programming, where emo sarchasm-machines are a stock member of every cookie-cutter "ensemble", right next to The Ethnic One and the Super-Crip.

      And people are sick and tired of the post-Modernist wallow.

      MLP:FIM is free of the infection, and its fandom is not consumed with it ("Cupcakes" and some of the more... agressive commenters here nonwithstanding). It is a body of work that has an essential joy to it that you simply do not find elsewhere. There are people whose idea of creativity involves positivity that isn't high-fructose-corn-fiction, and they have found a home.

      The floodgates are open. Hope you're ready for a wild ride...

      ReplyDelete
    174. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      Well then, that just begs the question of why? This is a very positive community, people are here to enjoy a very happy show and share the emotions they get from it. Why shouldn't they? If something makes people happy, why should they feel wrong for enjoying it, so long as it doesn't harm anypony else? You seem to have reservations about people turning it into a "philosophy," but really, if something, anything, can inspire people to at least try and better themselves, what difference does it make if that inspiration comes from a bunch of rainbow marshmallow ponies or the Catholic church?

      People are different, and enjoy different things, and there's nothing wrong with that. That's the entire moral basis of the show. Why you seem to want to bring people down for the way they see things is beyond me. To make a half-assed comparison, I hate pinkiedash. It makes no sense in my head, and I actually feel a little uncomfortable when I see it, but what does it matter to me if someone else enjoys it? No skin off my back.

      You say you're not cynical in the real world, so why be it here, in a place where people just want to get together and be happy with and for eachother? You've got some sort of moral high horse you've hoisted yourself on, and I can't pretend to know through what lens you see what you're doing here, but to everypony else, you're just being a giant dick.

      ReplyDelete
    175. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:14 PM

      @Anonymous
      Because in all honesty, these people didn't change because of the show, they changed all by themselves. They're just giving credit to a TV show. When I hear about fellow Aspies allegedly learning social skills from this show, I feel bad, because they have to give credit to a TV show, even though it was themselves and other people that did it.

      ReplyDelete
    176. In my case, I'd say it comes from having ponies on the brain and stumbling across a few cool ideas I had to put down on paper. I'm rather surprised just how well they turned out!

      ReplyDelete
    177. Why Ponies?

      There are some simple but important differences that may not be obvious at first about MLPFiM.

      One very important things to me is that the characters and the art are attractive! I get an aesthetic rush just looking at it. (there actually are scientific and psychological studies about this)

      A lot of the very interesting and well written animated shows have opted for an art style that is... well ugly. This is completely on purpose, and I have no problem with childlike or super-limited "doodle" style art. I just am not attracted to it. I can watch and enjoy the shows clever writing and music, but I have no desire to draw in that style, nor look at fan art.

      Otherwise, the characters are very well developed. I believe they have evolved beyond what even the show's creators believed possible. This is because creativity grows exponentially the more interested people are involved. The fandom reflects this trend also.

      Many of the plots of the individual episodes are cookie-cutter sit-com fare, but the extremely strong characters can make even a mediocre story shine. Think of "Seinfeld": it was a show about nothing, but with amazing characters, and it worked.

      In addition to the incredible show and it's creative team, the fandom itself has managed to be much more self confident and positively supportive then many fan communities. Fans create for themselves and for the response of other fans. Sites like EQD provide a way for large amounts of fans that aren't "insiders" to discover the wonderful creative content of the MLPFiM community. (I would not have become a Brony without EQD... I don't frequent chan sites and I don't care for snobish (often misinformed) animation blogs)

      I love the fans and the show because they are BOTH a cut above the norm.

      ReplyDelete
    178. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony So you're saying the show did nothing to help those who changed or start their own change?

      ReplyDelete
    179. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:18 PM

      @Anonymous
      In the words of an obviously blazed Big Macintosh
      "Eeyup"

      ReplyDelete
    180. And now I should probably say what it is about this show that makes me stick with it, even in between seasons. It's the show and the community. I love how it can be picked up anywhere in the series and understood and enjoyed. I love the openness of the world of Equestria. So many unfilled blanks just waiting for us to add our own creativity. For example, just what is Scootaloo's relation with Rainbow Dash? Think of how much speculation this alone has gotten. Hell, I'm working on my own fanfiction of what my theory is right now. Also, I love how sharp the writing is for this show. It's not easy to write something that's appropriate for little girls and still not make adults want to gag. All the geek culture references are truly appreciated by me and others I'm sure. And I love how the fans and staff interact. It's nice to see we have an impact on the show. Though I do hope it keeps it innocence and charm, and doesn't cater to us completely. Just a few shout outs and inside jokes are fine, but I hope this never becomes 'edgy.' I'm sick of edgy. I just want good, clean, noncynical, innocent fun. Which this show is. And last, I love this community. Everybody is so active, it's almost like the show has it's own fanmade spinoff series from all the fanart, music and fanfiction generated. It's truly mind-boggling.

      ReplyDelete
    181. my take on the whole thing, for male bronies anyway, is that as soon as you're hooked on the show you immediately have favorite (or maybe competing favorites) ponies; i think these female ponies represent several archetypal images of perfect women--even though they have their flaws.

      the fandom centers around that, and everyone making art, fanfic, games etc. is just an offering at the altar of the perfect, fun, innocent, and (for most of us) non-sexual, idea of woman and wholesome social interaction in general! those iconic ideas are almost primal...it's inspiring to me to think of it like that...whatcha think?

      ReplyDelete
    182. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony I beg to differ.

      Give us an example over how people change without going through revelation/a catalyst/a word from a good friend or family/a subject/an inspiration/etc.?

      Then we'll discuss.

      Because, believe it or not, people turn a blind eye on things which would help them, and often it takes a push to help them.

      Again, you are basing this all off your experiences. We are not learning social skills from this show, by the way, Dave. We are relearning how not to be a total jerk.

      I wasn't going to reply to you, but I feel that I have to defend. Calling people asspies for doing so is not fair for them, nor are you showing your logical side of claiming it to be so.

      If you want to express yourself, do so maturely instead of claiming these unsupported facts, and please don't degenerate into name calling. Your replies have, I repeat, no bite anymore.

      ReplyDelete
    183. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:25 PM

      @muninn
      This is a quote from a non Brony from a forum of mine
      "Guys like to watch this show because it shows incredible femininty, something that we don't see in most women. They're not sexually attracted, they're just attracted. Like I said earlier, the guys in Californication are like crazy bachelor players. That's why women like it.
      Only one of my friends is that feminine. She's just like these ponies. She wears army hats and stuff mischeviously yet is still incredibely so."

      ReplyDelete
    184. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:28 PM

      @sandman
      Firstly, I'm an Aspie, Aspie being somebody with Aspegers. Secondly, personality changes are only caused by one person, you.

      ReplyDelete
    185. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony My mistake then, and my apologies, but I believe I have still made my point.

      Again - a reply with no basis. I shall go and eat my toast now.

      ReplyDelete
    186. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:33 PM

      @sandman
      I think this all stems back to my Aspergers, one of my weakness's is expanding on my ideas.

      ReplyDelete
    187. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony

      Look man, if that's what this whole drama was about, then it's probably best to just end it here. What you're debating is inherently a psychological question; is personal change a reaction to external stimuli, or can it be initiated from within. Honestly, as interesting as that question is, there's a better time and place for it than here. Because right now, it's ponytime.

      ReplyDelete
    188. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony So a person place or thing can't inspire someone to make changes within themself? Sir that doesn't make any sense.

      ReplyDelete
    189. Dave Mustang, the cynical BronyJuly 7, 2011 at 11:34 PM

      @PaxImbrium
      Alright, we'll end it.

      ReplyDelete
    190. I think, in a way, both Dave and the rest of you are correct. True, an outside influence can steer you in the direction of change, but ultimately, the change has to be done from within. Does this make sense to anybody?

      ReplyDelete
    191. @Dave Mustang, the cynical Brony Unless someone else supports your claims, it is still baseless, unfortunately. What I have presented were facts - numbers, examples from other fellow bronies, etc. If it is what you feel, then do what I do when I see something which displeases me: close the internet webpage now. It is not hurting you and it is not hurting anyone. It is pointless, useless, and repetitive.

      I won't reply to this any longer, so I will just wish you have a good day.

      ReplyDelete
    192. @Jeremy I think it's true as well - it's your choice to open your eyes or not, but it still won't change the fact that sometimes, some people do need the push at the right direction.

      .... aanyway, I think Dave, at that point, turned philosophical himself. Why ask questions when we can PARTY? 8D

      ReplyDelete
    193. Okay, I can't seem to get this whole thing into one post, so I'm gonna split it.

      I think there are three main factors associated with MLP that come together to create the vast well of inspiration that causes its fans to explode with creative energy.

      The first factor is that MLP has successfully created its own universe with its own mythology and natural laws and whatnot. I find that any form of media that can pull off world-building successfully tend to get the biggest and/or most devoted fanbases (Harry Potter, Star Trek, Lord of the Rings), and they provide plenty of opportunities for fans to explore areas of the universe that are left unexplored by the original authors. We already pretty much know how the human world works, so it's very difficult for us to find unexplored areas of science that wouldn't go over the audience's heads. However, in the pony world, there's plenty stuff we don't know about, and it's all ripe for the picking as far as artists and writers go.

      A second factor is the show's focus on individuality. The mane six are all very different characters from each other, and they all get about equal coverage. The one-shot ponies tend to be pretty unique as well. Episodes that focus on individual ponies tend to celebrate what makes them unique, as well. What this means is that, not only will all types of fans inevitably find some pony they're especially attached to, thus forming a special connection with the show, but it means the fans themselves are also encouraged to express their individuality, and this inevitably ends up in the form of art in many cases.

      The third factor is the show's focus on friendship. First off, there are not many shows that are as heavily focused on friendship as MLP is, at least not without being unrealistic about it. MLP acknowledges that friendship can be rough at certain times, but at the end of each episode, it's still shown to be the most important thing there is. There are just not many shows that have this kind of message, and I think a lot of people who are sick of the rampaging cynicism present in other forms of media have found MLP's messages to be especially encouraging and inspiring.

      ReplyDelete
    194. However, the focus on friendship directly ties in with the focus on individuality as well. Generally, when I see other media encouraging messages of individuality, it effectively encourages that you break off ties with other people in some way in order to achieve it. MLP doesn't do that. Instead, it not only suggests that can you be different from your friends and still be good friends with them, but it also suggests that the very fact that you are different from your friends is what makes you a good friend. I don't think I've seen anything else carry this kind of message, which is a shame, because really I think it does a better job of encouraging people to be true to themselves than the usual be-true-to-yourself type of message.

      So, in summary. The show creates a vast universe that has plenty of potential for creative pursuits. The focus on individuality draws in many different types of fans, and encourages them to be creative. The focus on friendship provides a unique and positive message that inspires fans to an even greater degree, and it further encourages fans to express themselves simply by way of telling them that they have something valuable to contribute simply by being who they are.

      Of course, it doesn't hurt that the sheer amount of creative output that has been released as a result of all this only further inspires other fans to make their own stuff and contribute. At some point--if we haven't reached this point already--the fan stuff will continue getting produced simply through the sheer inertia of fan stuff being produced.

      ReplyDelete