Author: Kegisak
Description: An excursion into Manehatten with his sisters finds Big Macintosh face to face with his favorite author, Silver Tongue. It just so happens that Big Mac is just the sort of pony that Silver Tongue has been looking for - someone he can tell a very special story.They Never Fall Far
Additional Tags: None
20 kommentaari:
....
VastaKustutawait....
what just happened...
Do they both know?
come on theyre both too smart to not know!!
or are you just teasing us!?!?
CONFOUND IT
Thank you so much for not spelling it out to us. Ever since he talked about his foal, I was worried you'd be writing a sappy reunion, but the way it played out was very good.
VastaKustutai didn't think i would cry.
VastaKustutaAnd then i did.
I read it, then i re-read it then i was like
VastaKustuta"WHADDAFU-
Oright they know..."
Very good. 5 *'s from me!
Applebloom's accent.
VastaKustutaPriceless.
Interesting...
VastaKustutaNot sure what to think. It feels pretty brief, but I don't feel as attatched to this OC that I normally do...
Not ending it with sap. Classy. Nice story.
VastaKustutaSo great.
VastaKustutaNot particularly sad but certainly was a good read.
VastaKustutaRealistic ending = 3 extra stars. Too bad I can't put 8/5, so just 5. 5 stars.
VastaKustutaSPOILER ALERT ALSO INTERPRETATION AND SPELLING OUT WHAT IS WONDERFULLY SUGGESTED BUT NOT SPELLED OUT
VastaKustutaEveryone should just assume spoilers in the comments, that's my opinion. Anyway, they both know. Actually, no. They both know the possibility exists. But the fanon is Big Mac and Applejack's parents died, so there'd be no real way of telling. So there is the suggestion, the hint that maybe Big Mac is Little Apple. Since Apple Bloom is there, I'm sure Big Mac wouldn't want to upset her with that suggestion. And it would be only that, suggestion. No way of knowing for sure. That's also why Silver Tongue gave Big Mac the note to read. Just in case.
Really guys? Really? Really. REALLY? Come on. And I did not cry but it was heartwarming. I'd rate it but blogger ate the rating box.
You get points for avoiding what could have very easily been a sappy story. Big kudos on keeping it classy.
VastaKustuta--SPOILER ALERT AND ALTERNATE INTERPRETATION--
I'd personally like to take the story as Big Mac not being the long-lost son in question here. The clues are obviously there, but I prefer the alternative in thinking it's coincidental.
The story was good. And that picture is so damn cute. Probably the cutest Applejack Picture I've ever seen. <3
VastaKustutaAgree'd with Kurogo, for
VastaKustuta-SPOILER-
I think it's best that Big Mac is the true brother of Applebloom and Applejack. Nonetheless, I liked this as a story. Like said before, no sappiness = kudos.
Men. Us men can be just as DRAMA as women, in our own way.
VastaKustutaVery nice read indeed. I was thinking "Oh no, the cliché is gonna come" A lot towards the end, but then... it simply didn't come. I really like how it ended and it was well written overally. 5/5
VastaKustutaI really enjoyed reading this story, even though the premise seems a bit far fetched Your writing style has a lot of potential.
VastaKustutaThe ending WAS sad in a way, but also appropriate I think.
VastaKustutaIf you really wanted you could maybe expand it into a longer story. But as it stands I think it works really well.
4/5
You sick SOB! I friggin loved it! Well played good sir well played.
VastaKustutaI love the picture and the Story. If I didn't know any better I'd say the picture was taken from one of the My Little Pony episodes but it wasn't, That gets an automatic 4 stars from me. And as for the story, it was great, I'm not really one to take time and read stories but this one hooked me in the instant I saw a southern accent being spelled out. Its fun deciphering those but the over all story was good, if it wasn't for the mentioning of death in the story I would have ask the My Little Pony writers to put this story in an episode, I would give this story a 5 star rating. With the picture and the story together that's 9 stars, unfortunately I can only give it 5 stars and a good complement, hopefully this comment will suffice.
VastaKustuta